mlb

Post-Combine Mariner mock draft

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

MLB has just finished up its annual amateur draft combine earlier this week, and we’re now two weeks out from day one of the 2026 Draft. The Combine brought to light some names I hadn’t studied closely (if at all), and reclarified some names I’ve had interest in off and on through this spring. So I thought I would put these names together in a new mock draft.

I’m still thinking the thesis of my last mock has some very strong grounding. Going into a potential MLB labor stoppage, and certainly some unknown changes under a new CBA; the 2026 Draft may be the league’s last chance to draft amateurs the way they currently can. It might be, not only the best way to hack this draft, but the best way to hack the next several years of drafts, is to go really hard this year on prep players. My goal is to find four prep players in this draft, and set up the timeline on another wave of player development.

I, personally, am still thinking that drafting prep LHP Carson Bolemon might be the best single pick the Mariners could make at #1.24. This, however, would be fairly unprecedented in the Jerry Dipoto era where the team has never drafted a prep pitcher higher than pick #55 overall. Plus, there is some national reporting that Seattle is specifically targeting a college pitcher, and another report talks about them looking to make an underslot pick that can help them finance overslot picks in later rounds. I don’t hate that.

So this mock is basically what it might look like to go underslot, college pitcher at #24, and then go hard on prep players thereafter.

#1.24 – RHP, UCLA, Logan Reddemann

Reddemann has had a pretty volatile spring…going from a guy looking at potential top 10 overall early in the season, then missing roughly six weeks at the end of the season with arm fatigue that dropped him down to late first to early second projection…after recently throwing a bullpen going about 90% at the Combine; he might be back on the rise up. I think this guy is maybe the second-best college pitcher in the class, so I’d be psyched to get him. He’s got a deep repertoire…he’s got velocity…he’s got control…if he was lefthanded, he’d be the perfect pick.

#2.65 – OF, Marist HS, Martin Shelar

The precedent for Seattle is really to look for prep, bat-first, lefthanded, shortstop types…which I was taking a long-hard look at. This draft has got some intriguing HS shortstops like Rocco Maniscalco, Will Plunkett, Taj Marchand. I actually really like that group. But as I watched some of the Draft Combine, I couldn’t help myself but to think, “is this the year to find a prep, righthanded, power-hitter?”

I’d previously been toying with the idea of Blake Bowen, but it was nearly impossible to repeat draft simulations where I could get him at #65. The Combine added some names with the same profile that could make it easier to plan for this strategy to be plausible. Guys like James Tronstein, Genson Veras, and Shelar. As I’ve dug into more of these guys, it has been Shelar that has risen to the top.

#3.101 – RHP, Georgia, Dylan Vigue

Vigue was a guy I was picking in my earlier mock drafts, but as the college season progressed he had started to have some difficult outings where his control was betraying him, which led to him center-cutting too many pitches, that SEC hitting was crushing. The Combine was a good reminder of what he does bring to the table: a plus sinker and a plus sweeper combo. I think this is a guy the Mariner pitching lab will like, and more importantly he’s a guy that they could probably polish up. I’m happy to have him back in the mock.

#4.129 – RHP, UCLA Cal Randall

In 2018 the Mariners drafted a Logan in the first round and a Cal in the third round; so why not run it back to run it forward?? What could go wrong? And they both happen to come from the same UCLA team. Total serendipity.

Randall might have the most upside of any pure reliever in this draft. The fastball is already 100mph and he struck out 16.5 batters per nine innings for the season. This could be a fast mover through the minors.

#5.162 – SS, Magnolia Heights HS, Christian Doty

After passing on the shortstop options in the second round; I wanted to find one with sneaky upside and a lower bonus demand in the middle rounds. I think Doty might be perfect.

#6.191 – LHP, Stony Brook, Micah Worley

Worley has been on my LHP shortlist for a while, but when I saw him catching 98mph at the Combine; I was sold. Listed 6’5″/230lbs, Worley posted a 3.12 ERA, 1.255 WHIP, 12.1 SO/9 and 4.0 BB/9 across 14 starts this year.

#7.220 – 1B/C, Miami, Alex Sosa

Sosa has been in my mocks before this, but in this version the fact that he has experience as a catcher becomes more relevant, as catcher has been sacrificed from the top ten rounds in favor of youth. Instead of a catcher in the top six rounds like I generally go for; in this mock I might end up going with quantity of catcher picks over quality.

#8.250 – RHP, Memorial HS, Cash Scarborough

I found Scarborough by sort of reverse-engineering the mock based on the bonus available, then scouting players that are projected to sign for that bonus amount in the simulator. Scarborough is a shorter pitcher listed 5’10″/190lbs. That seems too short, but Seattle did draft 5’11” Jurrangelo Cjintje in the first round two years ago. Marcus Stroman would be another hopeful comp.

The fastball is the current carry pitch for Cash and it has been up to 96mph with ride, and he also throws a promising slider.

#9.280 – OF, Pittsburgh, Lorenzo Carrier

Carrier has been a longtime member of my 2026 mocks, but I keep having to push him down my board due to his age in order prioritize other players.

#10.310 – RHP, Olathe West HS, Max Hamilton

Hamilton is one of my favorite players in the last two mocks I’ve done. I love when you’re digging in crates and you find a hidden gem. Any bonus savings I have in the first nine rounds I would push towards Hamilton to secure him away from his college commitment.

#11.340 – RHP, Oregon State, Isaac Yeager

#12.370 – C, Notre Dame, Mark Quatrani

#13.400 – SS, Nebraska, Dylan Carey

#14.430 – OF, Xavier, Clay Burdette

#15.460 – OF, Miami Ohio, Tommy Harrison

#16.490 – 1B, Baylor, Tyce Armstrong

#17.520 – LHP, Bowling Green, Ethan Stade

#18.550 – RHP, Clemson, Hayden Simmerson

#19.580 – OF, Northeastern, Harrison Feinberg

#20.610 – 3B, Toledo Troy Sudbrook

Mariner three week away mock

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

There was a report that surfaced this week breaking down MLB’s plans to restructure the entirety of amateur player acquisition as part of the impending CBA expiration and subsequent renegotiating. A few of the major points of the proposal for the domestic draft:

-banning the drafting of prep players altogether, and effectively making draft eligibility start at a player’s age of 20.

-shortening the draft from 20 rounds to 12 rounds.

-cutting the available signing bonus pool by more than $150 million per year.

-hard-slotting the bonus amounts rather than the current system of suggested slot bonus.

I haven’t heard/seen anyone thinking these ideas are good outside of Rob Manfred who is acting on behalf of MLB owners. The idea of installing a draft in place of the international signing period is particularly inconvenient for the Mariners who are projected to sign three of the top international prospects, including Mairon De La Rosa, who Seattle recently sniped from the Yankees when their verbal agreement fell apart. Under the MLB proposal, the 2027 signing period (typically in January of each year) would disappear completely, to be replaced by a draft that would take place in September 2027. They would also raise the international age eligibility from 16 to 18, thereby making all of Seattle’s 2027 agreements ineligible until, at least, 2028.

None of the reported draft changes would affect the 2026 domestic draft. At least, that’s what I was initially thinking. But as I’ve spent some time dwelling on these proposals; it occurs to me that their leaking into the media and then into the common knowledge could actually affect this year. Players coming from the 2026 high school draft class may now be incentivized to sign with their drafting MLB team for higher bonus amounts in 2026, than to risk the possibility of a slashed bonus pool, if not a hard-slotted possibility, should a new CBA pass as proposed.

Savvy MLB teams may seek to take advantage of these conditions and look to stock up on prep players this year, before their option to do so goes away entirely or even changes towards more restrictive. The only thing within the MLB’s reported draft restructure that benefits the players themselves would be the change in eligibility for college players from “after three years of college” to “after two years of college”. That proposal, in concert with the recent change in NIL money for college athletes, may be enough to sway 2026 prep players into honoring their college commitments this cycle. But, as far as I can tell, college baseball players aren’t cashing in on NIL money like, say, college football players. At the high end of baseball NIL money, my research suggests elite baseball players are making more like a max of $500,000 a year. Multiply that times the required two-years in college; and an elite college player is looking at, maybe, $1,000,000 in college earnings. So any 2026 draft bonus north of a million dollars could be enough to get most prep players signed to their drafting team this summer. In theory.

With this in mind…will it be possible for Seattle to sign an elite prep player at pick #24 for a techinically underslot figure?? The suggested slot bonus for pick #24 is $3,818,700. Could the Mariners find themselves with more prep options willing to sign at that pick for, say, $3.2million? An underslot deal in the first round is particularly appealing for Seattle this year as they currently don’t have a large bonus pool available. The Mariners’ total bonus pool is $8,218,200, which is the seventh-smallest pool in MLB this year. Saving money in the first round will make it easier to double, triple, quadruple down on prep players for the entire draft.

As I did in my last mock draft; I am cross-referencing my theoretical draft plan with a simulated mock draft via Over-slot.com. Their program includes a bonus element, but that element is non-negotiable. So the dollar amounts listed could vary widely from eventual actual bonus amounts.

#1.24 – LHP, Southside Christian HS, Carson Bolemon

Maybe a week ago Keith Law published a mock draft with the Mariners taking Bolemon here. At the time, I found the pick somewhat unresearched, as Seattle has never drafted a prep pitcher higher than pick #55 in the Jerry Dipoto era. But, if my new overriding theory of this draft is true, in light of this week’s news; Seattle may very well be considering prep players of either discipline earlier and more often than they ever have before. And…said pick(s) may cost less than ever before, so it could be two birds with one stone.

Bolemon ticks a lot of boxes for Seattle at #24, but one of those is how rarely they will reach and draft underslot players with their first round picks. Kade Anderson wasn’t a reach last year, but they did end up getting him for an underslot figure. Bolemon is ranked the #23 player in the class by mlb.com. Getting him at pick #24 is appropriate value, and then the signing bonus is TBD. My theory is that Bolemon will sign for underslot, but my simulator mock budgets for him to get exactly slot. So we can handle either pathway.

As a player, Bolemon reminds me of a very specific pitcher. I’m not going to reveal who, but suffice to say he would make a great pick. The calling card for him here, for me, is the overall pitchability. With the asterisk being the future upside including the potential to add some velo.

#2.65 – 3B, Mill Valley HS, Beau Peterson

Part of the hack of the draft simulator is that they place a bonus floor on certain rounds, so it actually benefits your overall mock to draft a high bonus player in the second round. You can’t aggressively underslot this early. So I’m adjusting my strategy to go prep-prep with the first two picks.

Peterson has a really strong hit-tool in his high school season where he hit .535/.650/1.536 with 3 HR, and 26 SB. The interesting thing is that he was also the winner of the high school homerun derby last year. So there is power within, but he’s not selling out average to get to his power. That’s tremendous discipline for a teenager.

#3.101 – OF, North Carolina, Owen Hull

I’ve started to think Seattle might be targeting outfield help with one of their early picks. That thought has coincided with my tendency to recency bias players that excel in the various stages of the College World Series. Owen Hull has been one of the biggest stars in the CWS and has now led the Tar Heels to this year’s Finals. On the season, Hull has hit .398/.506/1.121 with 8 HR, 26 doubles, 85 RBI, 18 SB, 47 BB, and 44 SO. In 2024 and 2025, before his transfer to UNC, Hull stole 42 and 29 bases for George Mason. So there’s a bit more speed there than, perhaps, the 2026 season might suggest.

Hull could be a true centerfielder with leadoff hitter traits. The Mariners current outfield situation has Randy Arozerana a free agent at the end of this season, Victor Robles has a club option for 2027, Rob Refsnyder may not make it on the team through the end of this season, Luke Raley under club control through his age 33 season after 2028, Dom Canzone is also under control through 2028 when he will be only 30. On the farm…Laz Montes has now played exactly 64 games at the AA level in both 2025 and 2026, and has shown some improvement in the second stint (14 HR, 39 RBI in 2025 to 20 HR, 54 RBI in 2026), but he’s still maxing out at a .237 average at the level. Jonny Farmelo has struggled to stay healthy and isn’t exactly dominating at Everett the way a first round pick should. Yorger Bautista is only hitting .226 in Arizona rookie ball. If you compare those top 10 OF prospects to the Mariners top 10 SS prospects (Celesten .308/.409/.880 in Everett and Becker .271/.432/.890 in Arizona); the shortstops have the current edge in performance. This may point Seattle’s draft interests more towards reinforcing CF than SS early on.

In terms of Hull, specifically…I wonder if you don’t try to go more of the Colt Emerson route, which would be to target the bat-to-ball player, but then to add power during the development. Also like Emerson…Hull seems to have very high intangibles including leadership.

#4.129 – RHP, Georgia, Dylan Vigue

There was a time in the middle of the college season that I had Vigue in every mock draft I did. He felt like a fourth round steal. But then he really seemed to scuffle over his last 5-6 regular season starts. In his start in the CWS Super Regionals vs Texas; I thought Vigue looked back to the form I saw from him at the beginning of the season. The foundation here is the sinker/sweeper combination which Vigue threw roughly 95% of the time this year. There are additional offerings in a cutter and a change that we really need to see more progress on.

#5.162 – C, Cal Poly, Ryan Tayman

Catcher is one of the positions I always try to include in the top six rounds of my mock drafts. Tayman is a nicely balanced hitter/defender at the backstop who can hit, hit for power, and throw. Down on the farm; Seattle’s top-ranked catching prospect, Luke Stevenson has regressed a bit in Everett after a hot start to his pro career in Modesto in 2025 where he hit .280/.460/.860 in 22 games. At Everett his line has dropped to .225/.410/.789 with only four homeruns in 50 games. There are no other catchers in the Mariners’ top 30 prospects. In previous mocks, I’ve had Seattle draft Texas catcher Carson Tinney in the second round. I don’t think that’s a crazy idea. Especially after Tinney was recently named the 2026 Division I catching Gold Glove winner. Tayman is a capable fallback plan.

Tayman hit .357/.447/1.119 with 18 HR for the year.

#6.191 – RHP, St Joseph’s, Christian Coppola

Coppola is a reliever by recent history, but I’m wondering/hoping if he doesn’t in fact have starter stuff. Either way, I think he is predominantly underrated on media big boards. I’m forcing his pick early to secure his services. Depending on the innings amount used to determine qualifiers; Coppola can be seen as the #1 pitcher in the country by SO/9. He had 16.6 to go with a 1.69 ERA, 0.884 WHIP, and 2.9 BB/9.

#7.220 – LHP, Texas, Luke Harrison

Harrison is a bit of a forced pick. I’m always looking for lefthanded pitching, especially starters, and Harrison looked pretty solid in his recent CWS start. Listed 6’2″/220lbs, Harrison has a season line of 4.10 ERA, 1.260 WHIP, 10.8 SO/9, 3.8 BB/9. He definitely looks like a guy that needs a season or two at Gas Camp to maybe build him up to a bit more velo.

#8.250 – OF, Pittsburgh, Lorenzo Carrier

Carrier continues to be in my mock since previous editions. Probably my favorite RHB in the college class. Being a senior-sign guy at 23 y/o is the only reason, I think, that he is available this late.

#9.280 – SS, HS, Christian Doty

From my favorite college RHB to my favorite prep RHB…Doty has probably my favorite swing and barrel rate of all the prep players. His future defensive position is probably a fair question, but that has also come in to play for previous Mariner prep shortstop picks like Cole Young and Colt Emerson that were drafted in the first round. That is one of the least important questions. If the bat plays; you will find a spot for him.

#10.310 – RHP, Oregon State, Isaac Yeager

For the longest time; it felt like the Mariners didn’t take drafting relievers seriously. That seemed to change, I want to say, two years ago when they really made a focused effort to draft quite a few high-value relievers. Some of those guys were quickly flipped in trades for MLB talent, but some (Charlie Beilenson and Brock Moore) are already at AA, which Seattle has frequently used as the true measuring stick for pitchers being MLB-ready (rather than AAA). I like this draft to, again, selectively take a couple fast-moving relief arms.

Yeager is a Seattle native, and I’d love for him to make his pro journey come through Everett, Tacoma, and Seattle. He’s a legit prospect coming from a pitching program in Oregon State that has ties to the Seattle player development program in the Beavers’ head coach Mitch Canham, the 2019 manager of the Arkansas Travelers. Yeager had a 2.04 ERA, 0.908 WHIP, 11.1 SO/9, 2.5 BB/9.

This is what this half of the mock looked like in the simulator. Glitch in the program lists the Christian Doty pick as Tyler Albanese, but note the signing bonus coincides more with a prep player’s bonus.

#11.340 – SS, Nebraska, Dylan Carey

Carey would be tremendous value at this round. He hit .353/.428/1.050 with 15 HR and was a finalist for the college Gold Glove at shortstop.

#12.370 – 1B, Baylor, Tyce Armstrong

Armstrong is one of the best righthanded power bats in the draft. He’s 6’4″/228lbs and hit .338/.453/1.211 with 24 HR in 56 games. He’ll turn 23 the week before the draft, which is the only reason he might fall this far.

#13.400 – C, Notre Dame, Mark Quatrani

Quatrani had a very strong year after transferring from Cornell to Notre Dame before this season. He hit .376/.457/1.100 with 15 HR. He doesn’t have the strongest throwing arm, but he’s a very good receiver.

#14.430 – RHP, LaTech, Declan Dahl

It’s tough to find depth starting pitching in the draft, so you kind of need to dig in crates of the smaller schools. Dahl is 6’3″/195lbs and pitched to a 3.54 ERA, 1.180 WHIP, 11.3 SO/9, and 2.5 BB/9.

#15.460 – LHP, Bowling Green, Ethan Stade

Stade would be a nice little upside play as a lefty pitcher. He had a 4.36 ERA, 1.141 WHIP, 14.5 SO/9, 2.8 BB/9. As of now his fastball is topping out at 92mph, but if we can add even 3mph to that; he could be at least a bullpen piece. I’m sort of picturing Brandyn Garcia who the M’s drafted in the 11th round in 2023 out of Texas A&M.

#16.490 – RHP, Coastal Carolina, Darin Horn

Horn is an overaged reliever without much velocity. So why draft him at all? The guy misses bats. He averaged 12.4 SO/9 with a 3.21 ERA, 1.262 WHIP, and 3.2 BB/9. If everything goes right; he might be Cooper Criswell.

#17.520 – RHP, Clemson, Hayden Simmerson

I really wanted to draft Taiwanese RHP Jui Chieh Lin with this pick, but I’m not really clear on his eligibility. He is currently pitching in the MLB Draft League but I don’t know if that is a de facto indication of draft eligibility.

I take Simmerson here instead, who may be poor man’s Cal Randall. He had a 3.62 ERA, 0.897 WHIP, 12.8 SO/9, 3.1 BB/9 in 32.1 relief innings for Clemson.

#18.550 – LF, Northeastern, Harrison Feinberg

I had a few outfielders that I liked at this pick, but I went with Feinberg because of how hard he plays on defense. This guy is a gamer. He hit .331/.440/1.037 with 16 HR and 42 SB for the year. He doesn’t even particularly read as that fast of a runner…but he seems to have that Josh Naylor feel for when to run.

#19.580 – RHP, Olathe West HS, Max Hamilton

Hamilton was the most last-minute addition to this mock draft. When I ran the simulator for the first ten rounds; using their pre-assigned bonus amounts; I had a surplus of $524,000 for all ten rounds. And that doesn’t factor that the Mariners may actually be able to get agreements for less than the simulator bonus amounts. If I can save another $326k on one or more picks; add that to my surplus, and add another $150k, which all picks in rounds 11-20 are allowed without penalty; I can offer another prep player a $1million signing bonus.

Hamilton is a bit of a two-way-player, but I like him on the mound. Listed 6’2″/208lbs, and there is something about his mechanics and his stuff that really speak to me.

#20.610 – 3B, Toledo, Troy Sudbrook

I like to backup my prep players in my mocks with college players at the same positions. It gives us a more developed option with which we can staff our farm teams throughout the summer as we release underdeveloping players from previous years’ drafts. Sudbrook hit .373/.467/1.132 with 11 HR, 32 doubles, and 13 SB. And he’s a solid defender at third.

Sudbrook has announced a commitment to Clemson in the transfer portal, but he will turn 23 y/o during the 2027 college season, so getting drafted may be the only thing he needs to stop him from setting foot on campus.

If Seattle can get Bolemon signed for closer to $3.5mill, and/or if they don’t manage to sign Doty in the 9th round…they will have enough signing bonus surplus to go after a prep player like Hamilton anywhere on day three of the draft and give him a seven-figure bonus. This may be the team’s last opportunity to draft prep players, so it makes so much sense to really try to stock up now.

Mariners one month away mock

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

The MLB Draft will begin day one of picks on July 11th, the national draft writers are putting out more sourced mock draft reports, so I thought it might be time for a new 20-round Mariner mock.

Let us begin with some of the most recently published mock drafts from national writers.

Jim Callis from MLB.com wrote over the weekend that, “the Mariners are targeting the same college arms as the Cubs” after previously saying the Cubs team and farm needed pitching, “which could lead to college options such as (Liam) Peterson, (Hunter) Dietz, (Tegan) Kuhns or (Cade) Townsend.” And then Callis makes one college arm addendum: “in addition to (Cole) Carlon”. Of that group; Peterson, Kuhns, Townsend are RHP, and Dietz and Carlon are LHP. Callis, with Peterson and Dietz off the board, gives the M’s Kuhns at pick #24.

Keith Law in his mock draft from early this morning went another direction with his rumor: “I’ve heard Seattle as one of the few teams on high school pitching in the first round,” and then specifically cites Carson Bolemon, Logan Schmidt, or Brody Bumila. He doesn’t specifically state they are targeting LHP, but all three of the names he mentions are prep LHP. His last comment is that if not one of the prep LHP; Seattle will “probably” pick a player with an under-slot deal. A couple thoughts: 1) the M’s have never drafted a prep pitcher higher than Ryan Sloan and Sam Carlson both at #2.55. 2) the M’s rarely go underslot with their first pick. Kade Anderson was an underslot deal last year from the #3 overall pick, but he still got $8.8mill. This year; Seattle’s entire draft bonus pool is only $8.2mill for all of the first ten rounds. The idea of the M’s two preferred options being a prep pitcher (who will most-likely cost overslot money) or a player that will sign for underslot money are contradictory. With their very limited bonus pool this year; an underslot pick makes a ton of sense, but then why would they also be looking at expensive prep pitchers. None of this really tracks, to me.

The other national mock I looked at came from a group-effort from the staff at Just Baseball published yesterday. In the alternating mock from four writers; Conor Dorney ends up representing the Seattle pick, and he mentions the M’s on college pitching, and specifies Tegan Kuhns, Cole Carlon, Jack Radel, and with Kuhns off the board; he gives the M’s Cade Townsend.

So after three mocks, the names specifically mentioned for Seattle:

RHP Liam Peterson
LHP Hunter Dietz
2x RHP Tegan Kuhns
2x RHP Cade Townsend
2x LHP Cole Carlon
LHP Logan Schmidt
LHP Brody Bumila
LHP Carson Bolemon

If we sort of Venn-diagram the data points from these three mocks; obviously we’re focused on pitching.
73% of the name mentions are college pitchers.
55% of the mentions are LHP.
45% are RHP and also college RHP.
27% are college LHP.
27% are prep LHP.

The two biggest data sets are college and LHP. Which then points us towards the Venn of Dietz and Carlon. Dietz is off the board before pick #24 in all three of the aforementioned mocks. That leaves us with Cole Carlon.

Carlon is a 6’5″/230lb lefty that pitched ASU to a 3.87 ERA, 1.195 WHIP, 14.3 SO/9, 3.3 BB/9 season line. He features a pitch mix that includes a fastball that has touched 100.7 mph, and a plus slider. There is also a curve and change with lesser present grades. When I watch Carlon; I see a bunch of Gabe Speier mechanically, but obviously Carlon has about 5 mph more velo, and has a full college season of proof of concept that he can start.

Honestly, of the names that have been reported; the two that I personally have been looking at are Cade Townsend and Cole Carlon. I also really like Logan Reddemann, but after he was shutdown by UCLA in April for “arm fatigue”; we’ve not seen him getting much draft buzz in the first round. The Mariners rarely give innings to their early-round pitching draftpicks in the summer of their draft; so I don’t think it’s beyond reason that they would draft a pitcher with a known current injury. Bryan Woo was drafted with a known injury, Brody Hopkins was iirc, to name a couple. But…those guys weren’t drafted in the first round. We can, perhaps, look to do this in a later round.

For now…I’m not too mad at the idea of blending some national reporting on Mariner interests with my own eval. Carlon ticks a lot of boxes. If Seattle were to look at one of the prep LHP (and even throw Gio Rojas in there); I think I might go with Carson Bolemon. Bolemon has the least velo of the three, but probably the best pitchability, and then I just really get the sense he’s a whip-smart, mature for his age young man. He feels like a Cole Young, Colt Emerson, Ryan Sloan kind of personality.

In financial terms on Carlon…I have him in the simulator signing for $3.5mill, which would technically qualify as underslot the $3.8mill allowed for pick #24.

#1.24 = LHP, Arizona State, Cole Carlon

As I just alluded to; I see no reason not to project the Mariners will draft a pitcher with current, known arm injury. Their previous years of pitchers picked in the top two rounds will sit out the remainder of the 2026 summer and fall, with the Mariners overseeing their entire offseason and spring ramp-up.

Jacob Dudan is one of the names that qualify for this. Dudan was shut down by NC State on, roughly, April 4th, and he had Tommy John surgery on April 29th (per his own twitter). He will be down and in recovery for a minimum of a year, which could still see him make his professional debut in 2027. The other thing to consider is the shape of the Mariner’s organization for starting pitching. We literally have a six-man rotation in MLB as of today. Kade Anderson is, arguably, MLB-ready in AA right now. Ryan Sloan is also in AA, but showing some growing pains and needing more time. Logan Evans is on the IL, but still has some upside once he’s back healthy. And, if you’re a psycho for watching prospects like me, LHP Mason Peters has a sub-2.00 ERA across his first ten starts at low-A ball after being picked in the 4th round in 2025 (and also sitting for the summer after he was drafted).

This sounds like an over-abundance of riches in our starting pitching…why am I mocking two pitchers to start this mock? Because I basically just named every starter in the organization that has more than four starts and an ERA under 4.00. (Also: Evan Truitt 3.88, Colton Shaw 3.91, Nico Tellache 3.28, Dylan Wilson 1.86) The Mariners barely have any other starters ranked in their top 30 prospects (Griffin Hugus – yet to pitch, Teddy McGraw – now reliever, Michael Morales – third year in AA, Chia-Shi Shen – struggling in A-, Marcelo Perez – relief, Grant Knipp – relief, Robinson Ortiz – relief, Po-Chun Lin – mediocre in rookie ball, Charlie Beilenson – relief, Tyler Cleveland – relief, Lucas Kelly – relief, Jackson Steensma – injured).

Now…why do I see Seattle making a big, early round investment in Dudan knowing his health status? This guy screams Mariner pitching lab, to me. Listed 6’2″/191lbs, Dudan was touching 99mph this Spring on the sinker while also featuring a plus slider that borders on sweeper from his low-slot release.

Before his injury, Dudan had posted a 3.60 ERA, 1.100 WHIP, 11.2 SO/9, and 2.2 BB/9 in eight starts. I like that Dudan has a three-year sample of pitching in the ACC where he improved his control each year. And in 2026 he made the biggest improvement while also moving from the bullpen into a starting role. This just feels like a Seattle project.

#2.65 – RHP, NC State, Jacob Dudan

In recent years, Seattle has rarely drafted a prep player after the first two rounds with the expectation of signability. Nick Becker pick #57, Ryan Sloan pick #55 were second rounders. Before that: Aidan Smith pick #124 in 2023, Ashton Izzi pick #126 in 2022, Tyler Gough pick #276 in 2022, Michael Morales pick #83 in 2021. That’s it for the last six drafts. So it’s a little bit contrary to their trends to project any prep players from here forward. But I kinda like waiting to do it. Waiting to go prep player this year is additionally tricky due to our low draft bonus amount. We can, basically, draft four players that we can offer over a $1.00 mill bonus to, as long as the rest of our draft kind of focuses on “senior-sign” types that we can give minimal bonuses to.

As I said earlier; I’ve been running simulations for the Mariners this year, and the primary simulator available online includes a bonus element. The program essentially gives every college player ranked after the top 300 prospects a default bonus of $150k. MLB teams can technically give a player a bonus as low as they want (that the player agrees to), but I actually like giving them a floor of $150k. I mean, do you really want to draft a guy that is willing to sign for $25,000?? The chances of that player panning out are slim to none, and the difference between doing that and giving a three-year, living wage type bonus to a guy that has SOME upside is, like, $100k. Just do better accounting. And the Mariners have been, more or less, following this philosophy recently. In 2025, the M’s gave a minimum bonus of $50k to any single draftpick (17th round), and a minimum of $100k to all of their picks in the top 10 rounds. They gave bonuses of exactly $150k to six picks (rounds 11, 12, 13, 15, 16, 20).

The advantage of pushing prep players down to later rounds is that you can end up getting an appropriately ranked/drafted college player in the early rounds AND still getting a higher ranked prep player in a later round and just pay them the bonus of an early round pick. This, in theory, means we can get five top 100 players when we only have three picks in the top 101 overall (for example). The disadvantage of this strategy is that some prep players want BOTH the signing bonus money and the symbolic meaning of being an early round pick. You have to know your board and prenegotiate which players will still sign from a later round pick.

The most recent example of this was Aidan Smith in 2023. Smith was ranked the #78 overall player on the MLB big board. Seattle drafted him at pick #4.124, and they signed him for $1.2mill when slot money was $531k.

The other thing to consider in the prep player conversation is simply how terrible Seattle has been at developing the prep pitchers they have drafted over the years. Like, all of MLB kinda has trouble developing prep pitchers, but Seattle definitely has zero hits doing it in the Dipoto era. So it’s just terrible ROI to do it. Now, do they have a better argument about developing prep HITTERS? Certainly it feels like they have a stronger argument this year when Cole Young and Colt Emerson are representing 50% of their MLB infield, and Julio Rodriguez was developed from his teenage signing as an international player.

With all of these factors in mind; I like the way the board lines up this year to have select spots across the draft where I’m filling gaps in my college board with overslotted prep players. And those happen to be more of the hitting variety.

The first prep player I’m drafting is Mill Valley 3B, Beau Peterson. It’s not always easy to find prep players’ season stats, but I think I have a fairly accurate listing of Peterson’s season as: .535/.650/1.536 slash with 3 HR, 26×29 SB, 28 BB, and only 5 SO. I thought he was gonna have a better power number as he has previously won a high school homerun derby in one of the HS exhibitions. Regardless, I’m happy to draft the hit tool and look to add some game power.

#3.101 – 3B, Mill Valley HS, Beau Peterson

The fourth round is an interesting pivot point for me. I lowkey think we need to add another starting pitcher because those names dry up quickly after this if we don’t. But that would make three SP in our first four picks…should it be a bat for balance? The Mariners rarely target balance in their drafts. They will go hard on SP if the draft calls for it. They will draft three or four prep bats if the class and their bonus pool allow for it. Those logical thoughts don’t necessarily come into play like we think they might.

Having said all that…when I ran the simulation; I found the most exciting player consistently available to draft at this pick is actually a reliever.

#4.129 – RHP, UCLA, Cal Randall

Cal Randall is a thickly built 6’4″/235lb righthander that pitched in 34 games in 2026 where he posted a 3.19 ERA, 1.097 WHIP, 16.5 SO/9, 5.5 BB/9. He actually gives up more walks than he does allow hits for the year. He works primarily from a double-plus fastball that touches 101mph, and has exceptional metrics in terms of release height, extension, IVB, etc. He also throws a change-up and a slider. If the pitching lab can do similar for Randall what they’ve done for Brock Moore (5.8 BB/9 as senior at Oregon, 3.0 BB/9 between Everett and Arkansas in 2026); they’ve got a future closer on their hands. And a quick mover through the minors.

At this point of the draft; my board suggests we can really start rolling through some underrated, high upside college bats. I think you always want to draft a catcher in the top six picks, or so, and that ends up lining up nicely to be my first pick in this stretch.

#5.165 – C, Cal Poly, Ryan Tayman

Tayman is listed 6’2″/210lbs, and has a really nicely balanced skillset as hitter and receiver. He is only 20 years old, but has two years at Cal Berkeley before this year at Poly where he hit .357/.447/1.119 with 18 HR, 19 doubles, 31 BB, and 50 SO. He was the central figure in the Mustangs roster that made a run in the College World Series in the last couple weeks.

#6.191 – OF, Pitt, Lorenzo Carrier

Carrier is just one of my favorite bats in this whole draft. Listed at 6’5″/215lbs, Carrier hit .387/.534/1.318 with 20 HR, 15 doubles, 6×6 SB, 57 BB, 62 SO on the year. The only reason he is hypothetically available this late is that he is already 23 years old as of May, and maybe he’s limited defensively.

#7.220 – RHP, St Joseph’s, Christian Coppola

Honestly, I’d be a little surprised if Coppola was available this late. He’s a 6’5″/230lb righthander that primarily pitched in relief in 2026, but who had 25 starts for Rutgers between 2023-24, and recently made a three-inning start for Trenton in the summer MLB Draft League. There may be a chance he goes back to starting, which is a big part of why I want him after choosing to draft a reliever over a starter in the 4th round.

In 2026, Coppola finished with a 1.69 ERA, 0.884 WHIP, 16.6 SO/9, and 2.9 BB/9 in 12 relief apperances and one start for St Joseph’s.

#8.250 – 1B/C, Miami, Alex Sosa

I’m acknowledging Sosa has experience as a catcher, but every time I watched the Hurricanes from, say, March until their season ended in the CWS regionals; Sosa was playing 1B. If Alex still has some catching innings left him that’s an awesome bonus cause he hits lefthanded, and that is always a nice commodity to have. Listed 6’1″/208lbs, Sosa hit .338/.448/1.119 with 18 HR, 16 doubles, 41 BB, 48 SO for the year. If he ends up only playing 1B…fine. He has the power to be a decent weapon (a la Josh Naylor) as a 1B.

#9.280 – SS, Magnolia Heights HS, Christian Doty

The Mariners have had some of their best draft success going after prep shortstops, and so I have them drafting another one (with some hidden value being available late in the draft) in Doty. Listed at 6’1″/190lbs, Doty has one of my favorite righthanded hit tools in this class. He comes from Olive Branch, Mississippi which may sound familiar to Seahawk fans who might recognize Olive Branch as the high school origin of former Seahawk, KJ Wright.

Again, stat lines on prep players can be hard to find, but I show Doty’s 2026 season as: .492/.609/1.351, 6 HR, 20×20 SB, 27 BB, 10 SO. He has a college commitment to Ole Miss, so we will of course need to give him overslot money. The simulator I use doesn’t allow you to alter the bonus money offers to players, so the screenshot below will show him at an even $1.0mill bonus, but you will also be able to note that I finished the top ten picks with $310k of surplus…all of that will also go to Doty to bring his bonus up to $1.3mill.

There is a glitch in this mock draft simulator where most of the rankings after like #250 have duplicate names. So there are two players that are listed as #386 on the simulator big board, Christian Doty and Tyler Albanese. The correct player shows up as the simulation rolls (see directly below), but then it is the other player at the conclusion of the draft, which I also show further down.

#10.310 – RHP, Oregon State, Isaac Yeager

Oregon State had a really nice pitching staff this year, and I seriously considered multiple names from their team across this whole mock. I like LHP Ethan Kleinschmit in the 2nd or 3rd round, I like RHP Eric Segura in the 4th round slot where I took Randall. I like reliever Wyatt Queen wherever we can get him.

I ended up only mocking Yeager, but I’m really happy to get him. He’s a former UW Husky who originally comes from Bishop Blanchet HS in Seattle, so this will be a homecoming for him. Listed 6’6″/255lbs, Yeager looks more like a Husky tightend than a reliever, but he had a 2.04 ERA, 0.908 WHIP, 11.1 SO/9, 2.5 BB/9 for the year. He throws a fastball sitting 95mph, and a plus slider as his out-pitch.

Here is the screenshot of my simulation run of the top ten round picks.

#11.340 – SS, Nebraska, Dylan Carey

With the signing of Christian Doty potentially a question mark; it’s important that we draft another shortstop that we know we can sign because, ultimately, we still have to fill a farm system with players that can play innings for the next three years, or so.

I actually really like Carey. He’s one of three college SS this year that I found that I really ended up liking for their on-field skills and intangibles. There was Tyson Leblanc who was the clutchest hitter for the Kansas squad that made a deep run in the CWS, and who is now projecting to be off the board before pick #65. There was Jake Schaffner who played SS for North Carolina and who has a really nice glove. And there is Carey who seems to be the one with the lowest profile that we can still get outside of the top ten rounds.

Carey hit .353/.428/1.050 with 15 HR, 16 doubles, 21 BB, 49 SO this year. He also plays a very solid defensive SS.

#12.370 – C, VMI, Cole Raile

Even if Alex Sosa ends up playing some catcher; I don’t think it’s terrible for Seattle to draft three. They end up being useful trade pieces. Seattle drafted three catchers in 2025 (Luke Stevenson, Luke Heyman, Grant Jay) and have already traded Heyman to Boston in the Alex Hoppe deal.

Raile is really an interesting player. He’s one of the more athletic catchers you’re going to find. He has power (16 HR), he has a great arm (33% caught stealing), and he can run (24×26 SB). We probably can’t get him this late, but c’est la vie.

#13.400 – 1B, Baylor, Tyce Armstrong

Armstrong is another guy I have no clue of his true value. Most draft boards don’t even list him, which could mean he’s lower than top 500 names, but he hit .338/.453/1.211 with 24 HR, 14 doubles, 35 BB, 54 SO, so why wouldn’t MLB teams want him at decent price? Like, this isn’t a profile of a guy that is selling out strikeouts to get to his power. He’s a little overaged in that he will be 23 the week before the draft, but that’s a minor issue in my opinion if the upside holds, and he moves fast.

#14.430 – RHP, Clemson, Hayden Simmerson

Simmerson was a recent find for me and I’m wondering why he’s not ranked higher, but whatever. I don’t make the rules and I don’t make the bugs. Simmerson is listed 6’2″/205lbs and had a 3.62 ERA, 0.897 WHIP, 12.8 SO/9, 3.1 BB/9 with 4 saves in 19 relief appearances.

#15.460 – LHP, Bowling Green, Ethan Stade

It’s always good to look for depth lefthanders, especially if they can start. Stade had a 4.36 ERA, 1.141 WHIP, 14.5 SO/9, 2.8 BB/9 in ten starts and four relief appearances. The peripheral numbers are better than the ERA.

#16.490 – RF, Miami Ohio, Tommy Harrison

Harrison had a massive season playing in the MAC this year, but he’s showing his flaws after 16 plate appearances in the MLB Draft League. In the college season he hit .386/.507/1.205 with 17 HR, 16 doubles, 41 BB, 33 SO.

#17.520 – RHP, Coastal Carolina, Darin Horn

Horn is an interesting profile. He’s listed 6’4″/200lbs and had a 3.21 ERA, 1.262 WHIP, 12.4 SO/9, 3.2 BB/9. He doesn’t have much velo, but he does enough with movement and deception that he strikes guys out. His ceiling might be kind of a Cooper Criswell profile, but that’s well worth the pick this late.

#18.550 – LF, Northeastern, Harrison Feinberg

When I discovered Feinberg I really liked his game. Listed 6’1″/210lbs, he hit .331/.440/1.037 with 16 HR, 15 doubles, 42 SB, 37 BB, 52 SO. And the guy plays all out on defense.

#19.580 – RHP, Seton Hall Prep, JJ Drennan

With the structure of this draft; you basically need to draft a prep player late like this as a guy you can offer big money to in case one of your prep players from the top ten rounds falls through and you end up with a bunch of surplus bonus money. I figure it’s better to try this move with a prep pitcher than hitter because of the Mariners’ reputation for developing pitching. Drennan is from New Jersey and has a commitment to Boston College. Neither of those is known as a hotbed for baseball talent, so there might be a bit more flexibility to sign him away from his college commitment.

#20.610 – 3B, Toledo, Troy Sudbrook

Sudbrook is 6’3″/205lbs and hit .373/.467/1.132 with 11 HR, 32 doubles, 13 SB, 30 BB, 40 SO. Seattle doesn’t really draft and develop third basemen, they prefer to draft shortstops and convert them, so I like drafting one with the knowledge he already is a 3B.

I’m currently pretty happy with this mock. It’s fairly balanced, which I generally like even though Seattle will never necessarily force a balanced draft.

I predominantly think the best players available in the first round are pitchers…either prep or college. I would love a Logan Reddemann pick.

I think there are interesting options in the second round. I love Texas catcher Carson Tinney, but a second round catcher feels rich with Cal Raleigh in the bigs and a Luke Stevenson pick in the second last year. I think prep outfielder Blake Bowen would be super interesting as a guy built like a linebacker but who can hit, run, and throw at elite levels.

I really like LHP Ethan Kleinschmit if he falls to the third round.

I really like a number of college RHP starters in the fourth round including Declan Dahl, Eric Segura, Cal Scolari, Josh McDevett, and maybe Dylan Vigue if the Seattle pitching lab can fix him. Also a Minnesota RHP named Isaac Morton, who also I believe has needed TJ surgery recently.

I like a number of prep pitchers at various rounds. I like LHP Carson Bolemon a lot. I like Kaden Waechter, who reminds me a bit of Bryan Woo. I like Kaiden McCarthy who is a 17 year old that reclassified to the 2026 draft, and likely WANTS to sign, and who already is touching 99mph. I like Washington prep pitcher Eli Herst. I like a guy named Harrison Pollina, who isn’t even on the list of over 1000 players within the simulator I used.

And there are so many college bats I like that kinda feel like they fall in the no-man’s-land areas between Seattle picks, but don’t seem worthy of a reach, but also don’t seem likely to drop to the next round’s pick. Andrew Williamson, Ace Reese, Logan Hughes, Caden Sorrell, Tyson Leblanc, Gavin Grahovac, Dee Kennedy, etc. But when I like my later round guys as much as those top, say, 125 names…I just would rather take the pitcher early because I don’t have the midround pitching names that I like as much. So this is where I end up.

Mariners offseason plan

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

I’ve been spending some time this weekend thinking about what the Mariners could do this offseason, after signing Josh Naylor, to improve upon their 2025 season. What combination best fills the holes of free agency while staying within the structure of budget that is certainly at play from ownership?

This is what I came up with.

I’m sure this won’t be the most popular structure, and I’m fairly certain the front office has a plan that will be perceived more popular, but this is my pretty objective thought.

#1 – Sign one of the posted Japanese players.

It’s been a minute since Seattle has had a substantial Japanese presence on the roster, but I think there is value, both on the field and off, to be found there.

I’ve targeted 3B/1B Kazuma Okamoto as the Japanese signing I would pursue. Yes, he is the older of the two big bats, but the power is not that much less, and I think the pitch recognition is so much better and should travel. I think many people think Okamoto is JUST a first baseman, but I like his tape at third, where he won Gold Gloves as recently as 2022, I believe, to be adequate to replace Eugenio Saurez.

As far as Geno…it’s hard to say goodbye to him. I think he brought an emotional character to the clubhouse that was important in both of his stints here. If Geno would be willing to take the same money as I’m proposing Kazuma takes; I would probably just keep the continuity with Geno.

Speaking of the contract…most industry writers project Okamoto gets 3-4 years, and then it’s a pretty wide range of money from, like, $12 to $16mill AAV. I’ve budgeted him at three years, $40.5 million, or $13.5mill AAV.

#2 – Trader Jerry season.

We may NEED to see some trades this winter. Having spent on Naylor, and with the club expected to spend decently on someone else in free agency, we’re going to need to augment the roster with some younger, cheaper, but still MLB-proven, players. We have the farm system that should support making some of these moves.

Trade #1: In my model, I found that if Jorge Polanco gets the contract he’s projected to get; it will be one of the better values in all of MLB. If Seattle does go that route…hey, cool. It’s probably not a bad move. But I, personally, just worry about extending too many of these players that are aging out of their prime.

So, my first trade would be to send the #75 prospect in all of MLB, and the #7 prospect on the M’s top 30, OF Jonny Farmelo, plus our #18 prospect, RHP Michael Morales, to the St Louis Cardinals for IF/OF Brendan Donavan.

The Cardinals have the #5 prospect in all of baseball, JJ Weatherholt, set to debut in 2026, so they’re going to need a position for him to play, and so maybe they make Donovan available.

Donovan has position flexibility, but he spent 82 of his 97 starts last year at second base, and that will be where I pencil him in for Seattle in 2026.

In terms of the return going to the Cards…honestly, this is my most important trade, so I give them their first choice of any of our #6-#8 prospects, Michael Arroyo, Farmelo, or Jurrangelo Cijntje. But when I looked at their farm system; it just felt like they could use outfield help more than 2B or pitching.

Donovan is an Arbitration-2 player about to turn 29 in January, with club control through 2027, and he should cost roughly $5.75mill this year. Last year he hit .287/.353/.775 with 10 HR, 50 RBI in 118 games.

Trade #2: In order to replace some of the power lost by Polanco not being re-signed; I’m going to try to add some in the outfield. I am sending the Detroit Tigers #8 prospect SHP Jurrangelo Cijntje plus OF/IF Luke Raley in order to acquire OF Kerry Carpenter.

Carpenter destroyed Seattle in the postseason, so Mariner fans may have some mixed emotions about this one, but Carpenter is a 28 y/o who hit 26 HR in 130 games last year, with a slash line of .252/.291/.788, but a career OBP of .322, so we’re gonna try to straighten some of that back out.

Raley ends up the short straw between he and Dom Canzone in terms of who we would prefer to retain as a bench lefty outfielder. His ability to backup 1B is also now covered by Okamoto. There just really isn’t space for him, and he’s also the more expensive of he and Canzone, as he was projected to make $1.75mill next year. That’s not nothing when we’re pushing as hard as we can up against the “salary cap”.

Carpenter has three years of club control remaining, and he should cost about $3.5mill this year depending on arbitration. He may end up in true platoon with Victor Robles in right field, as Carpenter hit righties at a .257 clip while Robles hit .213 against them, and then Robles hit lefties .289 while Carpenter hit .217 off them.

I’m sure a lot of fans, and probably the front office, bristle at the idea of trading away Cijntje, but we’re holding onto Ryan Sloan and 2025 first rounder Kade Anderson, who probably fit better in the timeline of our pitching development/cost progression anyways. I felt like we NEEDED to part with someone quality to get an MLB player with “now” ability and cheap club control. That looked like Cijntje.

Trade #3: I’ve got a couple of smaller trades that fans may not immediately recognize, but trust me…I didn’t so much fucking homework on these. I’m sending 2B Cole Young to the Kansas City Royals for righthanded reliever Lucas Erceg.

Erceg kind of ends up a cap casualty for the Royals who have probably a tighter budget than Seattle, and will have multiple arbitration raises to work through. Erceg is a bit older as he will turn 31 early in the 2026 season, but he has club control through 2029, and should cost about $2.00mill this year. It’s not that different from when Seattle got ahold of Paul Sewald in his age 31 season.

Erceg has been a very solid reliever for the last two years between Oakland and Kansas City posting sub-4.00 ERA’s including a 2.64 mark last year. His strikeouts were down a bit in 2025, but his velo and pitch metrics are still very strong.

Young becomes somewhat expendable with Donovan acquired and Colt Emerson nipping at his heels in AAA already. Emerson may, eventually, be the replacement for JP Crawford at SS in 2027, but he probably has to start somewhere else when he debuts in 2026. In a scenario where Emerson plays 2B; Donovan could play LF with Randy Arozarena benched vs RHP. The Royals like this trade as they can either make Jonathan India available in trade immediately, or slot Young in as his replacement in 2027 and give him another year to develop.

Trade #4: This is the smallest, but perhaps sneakiest, trade of all. I’m sending #12 prospect OF Tai Peete to the San Francisco Giants for lefthanded reliever Erik Miller.

Miller is a big boy at 6’5″/268lbs and he posted a 1.50 ERA, but pedestrian 6.0 BB/9 and 6.6 SO/9 numbers across 36 appearances and 30.0 innings for the Giants in 2025. His season ended early when he was placed on the IL in early July with elbow soreness from which he never came back. Obviously, this trade would be contingent on a physical, but I like the “buy-low” nature here in order to acquire a lefty that touches 99mph with run. And he’s only 28 in February with club control through 2029 and should only cost $820k this year.

Even if the injury is still not fully resolved; there is enough meat on the bone that this could be a useful trade across the life of the deal. This could end up sort of resembling when Seattle acquired Andres Munoz while he was in injury recovery for the Padres. We got Munoz on August 30, 2020 after he didn’t appear at all for SD that season, and he didn’t pitch for Seattle until October 3rd, 2021.

After all of these transactions, the Mariner rotation remains fully intact. The defense should be better with Donovan > Polanco, and potentially Ben Williamson starting at 3B with Okamoto at DH. Power rates may be down a bit, but contact rates should be better (really, we are mistakenly taking credit for Saurez’ 49 homeruns, when in fact he only hit 13 for SEA). The farm system maintained our top 6 prospects, along with keeping guys like SS Felnin Celesten, C Luke Stevenson, OF Yorger Bautista, SS Nick Becker from the top 15. And we didn’t blow our remaining (expected) $23mill budget surplus on one guy. We’ve addressed 2B, 3B, OF, RHP, and LHP. We’ve got relatively younger without becoming inexperienced, and we’ve left room for minor league promotions.

New Roster:

C- Raleigh, Ford
1B- Naylor, Okamoto
2B- Donovan, Rivas
SS- Crawford, Rivas
3B- Williamson, Okamoto
LF- Arozarena, Donovan, Canzone
CF- Rodriguez, Robles
RF- Carpenter, Robles, Canzone
DH- Okamoto, Carpenter

SP1- Woo
SP2- Gilbert
SP3- Kirby
SP4- Castillo
SP5- Miller

CL- Munoz
RHRP- Brash, Bazardo, Erceg, Hoppe
LHRP- Speier, Miller, Ortiz

Mariner 2025 draft redux

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

The 2025 MLB Draft is now in the books. Teams have three more days, I believe, to sign their draftpicks from this class, and so we have bonus figures on over 80% of the total player pool. Something I’ve done for a few years now after the draft is to put together a post-draft mock that incorporates the actual draft position of players, as well as factoring the bonus figures they sign for, in order to document a plausible full draft that Seattle could have made.

My rules for this:

Obviously, I can’t draft someone at pick #35 that came off the board at pick #34. I do allow myself to “reach” on players as much as I want.

The 21 total draft selections must be players that have signed with their respective teams. I can’t pick a high school player, for example, that turned down opportunity to go pro in favor of attending college. I do allow myself to draft a player that went undrafted, but signed as UDFA.

The 21 players’ bonuses must total under the bonus pool Seattle went into the draft with, and, for picks in rounds 11-20, any bonus over $150,000 will count towards the bonus pool for rounds 1-10.

Lastly, it’s not a rule, per se, but I did have a guideline where I tried to draft the same as Seattle did in terms of position ratios. Seattle drafted 13 pitchers, 8 bats…so that was my target. If Seattle drafted three catchers…I tried to draft three catchers. But sometimes I would fudge a bit in order to match traits (power righthanded bat) instead of defensive position.

One more note before we start…I had heard before the draft that Seattle was struggling to find a way to actually spend the amount of bonus pool money they had, which was the second-biggest pool in all of MLB. I kind of get that now. It really was hard to find ways to spend the last, roughly $800-900k. Once you get out of the top 75 picks, or so, there really aren’t many high school players that received overslot deals, and that I also liked as prospects.

I had briefly considered taking someone other than Kade Anderson at pick #3 in order to see how a bigger underslot deal there could affect the rest of the draft. It really wasn’t going to do anything for me beyond the third round. And it wasn’t even much of a difference-maker in terms of who I could target in the top 100 picks.

So we begin the same as Seattle.

#1.3 – LHP, Louisiana State, Kade Anderson

The only other real thought for me here was to reach on Patrick Forbes. I really liked Forbes. Forbes was picked at #1.29 and signed for $3.00mill. That’s $5.8mill less than Anderson got. And I can’t take Forbes at the Mariners’ next pick at #35. The optics just don’t work.

I don’t love Anderson as a prospect. I think he’s more similar to Emerson Hancock than Logan Gilbert, etc. But Hancock has made it to the show, and he’s had some good stretches of pitching in Seattle. He may still get better in time. But if you re-drafted 2020 now and still took Hancock at #6 over Garrett Crochet (pick #11), Pete Crow Armstrong (pick #19), Jordan Westburg (pick #30); I think you’re crazy. There will be players taken after Anderson that are better than him. And Forbes might be one.

Obviously, Anderson maintains the same bonus of $8.8mill.

#1.35 – SS, Don Bosco Prep, Nicky Becker

This pick and the second round pick could be interchanged with no real difference in the grand scheme. I moved Becker up because as the actual draft was unfolding; I was uncomfortable with how slim the prep shortstop board was getting, and I would have pulled the trigger on Becker here.

He gets the same bonus here that Seattle gave him at #57: $2.75mill.

I am passing on Luke Stevenson because there is a lefthanded college catcher further down the board that I prefer.

#2.57 – LHP, Lyndon B Johnson HS, Johnny Slawinski

Seattle drafted a prep lefthanded pitcher in their actual 19th round in Cam Appenzeller, who quickly confirmed he was already on campus at the University of Tennessee and wasn’t sure why Seattle drafted him.

In my case, I get my favorite prep lefty, and he did sign with the Angels for $2.5mill.

#3.91 – 3B, Foothills HS, Tim Piasentin

This is the biggest move away from Seattle’s actual draft that I am making. Seattle did not draft any third basemen, and were pretty limited in the number of prep players they drafted. I thought all along leading up to this draft that the best move was to be aggressive on the upside of the prep players, rather than the high floor with little upside of the college class.

I liked Piasentin pre-draft, but had never really found a spot for him without knowing his bonus request. He signed with Toronto for only $747,500, which is only about $100k more than what Seattle actually spent on Griffin Hugus with their literal third round pick. I think that’s a steal.

#4.122 – RHP, UNCW, Zane Taylor

I had Taylor in my mocks pre-draft, and I still think Seattle should have drafted him. His now stuff profiles very well to me, and he cost $36k less than what they paid Mason Peters. The thing I noticed about Seattle’s actual draft class this year was that they seemed to be avoiding guys that were older, true “senior sign” candidates. Which, to me, is a weird thing to decide as a wholesale strategy. But Seattle drafted some older guys in 2024, and have had numerous injury issues from that class, so maybe this is their fix for that.

#5.152 – C, Wright State, Boston Smith

Again, Smith was in most of my mock drafts. He’s a lefthanded, power-hitting, good defensive college catcher. Very similar profile to Luke Stevenson. The difference is…age. Stevenson is only recently 21 years old…Smith will be 23 later this year. But…Smith’s hit tool, and eye at the plate are currently better than Stevenson’s.

Boston signed with the Nats for only $50k. So this is a huge savings to reallocate to other rounds.

#6.182 – RHP, Arizona St, Lucas Kelly

I had a couple other names I was interested in pre-draft, and they fit in this spot both selection-wise, and bonus wise (one of them could have actually saved an additional $75k), but part of my goal is to split the difference between my thoughts and what Seattle thought about how to structure this draft.

And Kelly has some interesting traits. Obviously, his velo stood out amongst this class. I feel like Seattle has gotten into some trouble when they’ve hunted pure velo if/when it came at the expense of other things like control, but they didn’t do a ton of that this year, so I’m gonna allow it this one time.

Kelly’s bonus stays the same at $325,000.

#7.212 – LHP, Old Dominion, Dylan Brown

I had more interest in finding some lefthanded options for Seattle in this draft. I’m not sure why they don’t prioritize them more. Even if Seattle analytics has some number that shows righthanded pitchers do better in TMobile Park, or something, there is still a ton of value that could be found by drafting, developing, and then trading lefthanders. As I’m sitting here writing this piece today; LHP Brandyn Garcia was just traded last night as part of the package for Josh Naylor.

Brown is a big-bodied southpaw at 6’5″/230lbs that started 15 games for Old Dominion this year. He could be similar to Garcia (who was 6’4″/235lbs) along his development path in that he’ll start for as long as he can, and then get moved to the bullpen once he gets closer to the big leagues.

#8.242 – RHP, William & Mary, Carter Lovasz

I first spotted Lovasz in 2024 when he was having a better year for W&M out of the bullpen. This year his numbers (mostly ERA and BB/9) took a big step backwards (SO/9 did tick up a bit to 13.4), and so I kinda stopped tracking him. But he signed with Atlanta for only $7500 in bonus money, which is very helpful to me.

The thing about mocking picks to Seattle…after they drafted some of the unknown pitchers they did, who didn’t have any particularly impressive stats…you’re pretty free to hunt traits in spin or break, etc, and not worry about stat lines.

#9.272 – LHP, Texas, Jared Spencer

In this particular spot; I need a slightly cheaper player than Jackson Steensma. Like, it’s only like $30-40k difference. In this case, I wasn’t intentionally looking for another LHP…I was prioritizing the signing bonus first. As a guy, like Steensma, who is coming off surgery (shoulder for Jared); Spencer only costs $165k, but arguably there’s more upside than with Steensma.

In the 10 starts Spencer made before surgery ended his season; he posted a 3.27 ERA, 1.223 WHIP, and 11.4 SO/9.

#10.302 – LHP, Georgia, Alton Davis

IIRC, I toyed with drafting Davis in some of my mock drafts. I’m coming back to him now knowing where he was picked and how much he signed for. He kind of reminds me of the Lucas Kelly pick because you’re counting on player development. This is far from a finished product. In fact, he’s pretty rough around the edges. But I love the stuff and the athleticism from a big 6’5″/181lb frame. Obviously, you try to put some weight on him and get him stronger.

His bonus is $397,500.

#11.332 – C, Ballard HS, Truitt Madonna

Madonna is a prep catcher that is from Seattle (Ballard HS), but who somehow evaded me in the pre-draft process. But he’s a 6’3″/215lb kid that hit .279/.360/.872 with a couple HR in 43 AB’s in the MLB Draft League against primarily college players.

With Harry Ford potentially on the trade block; it felt like Seattle could fit in its next high school catching prospect.

Madonna signed for $654k as an 11th-round pick of the Padres. $504k of this bonus will count towards Seattle’s bonus pool.

#12.362 – RHP, Wofford, Carter Rasmussen

It’s a little tough to know for sure how Seattle plans on using some of their pitching draftees in terms of starting vs relief, so it’s tough to match one for one with them. Rasmussen was a reliever for most of his career, and in 19 apperances last year at Wofford posted a 3.21 ERA, 1.196 WHIP, and 11.9 SO/9.

Rasmussen signed for $150k.

#13.392 – OF, Kent State, Jake Casey

I had Casey in my earlier mocks, and so I’m going to keep him over the likes of the late-round outfielders Seattle actually drafted in Aiden Taurek and Brayden Corn. I’m not totally sure what the appeal is on those guys. Corn had middling pop, decent basestealing, and middling plate discipline. Taurek had middling pop, middling basestealing, decent plate discipline. I’d say Casey has decent pop, decent basestealing, decent plate discipline.

He signed with Toronto for $150k.

#14.422 – C, Florida, Luke Heyman

I never put Heyman into my mock drafts, but looking at him after Seattle picked him; I kinda like the potential. He’s already one of the better defensive catchers in the class. The bat is kind of just solid across the board. The power isn’t extreme but he hit 13 HR, the plate discipline is neither extreme patience or overly swing-and-miss. This is a good range for a quality receiver that you hope to build the bat upon.

Heyman was Seattle’s only overslot bonus from rounds 11-20, so $80k of his signing counts towards the bonus pool.

#15.452 – RHP, Arizona, Casey Hintz

When I could, I kept Seattle draftpicks intact. In this case, I’m moving Hintz up a round cause that barely matters when there is no slotting. His bonus was and remains $150k. Seattle kinda drafted a bunch of weird, low-slot righthanders this year. I don’t know exactly why. My guess: they’re taking multiple stabs at finding the next Logan Evans. I’m trying to cut some of the fat, and trim that down to my favorite of the group, which was Hintz.

#16.482 – OF, Southern, Cardell Thibodeaux

Seattle drafted some outfielders from pretty small schools in Brayden Corn from Western Carolina and Aiden Taurek from Saint Mary’s, so it doesn’t feel far-fetched to draft Thibodeaux. Thibs was one of the best hitters in the country last year and his signing bonus is $150,000.

#17.512 – RHP, Anthony Karoly

Karoly remains from Seattle’s actual draft. It’s tough to find video of Karoly throwing, but the statline is interesting: 4.18 ERA, 1.214 WHIP, and 16.9 SO/9.

#18.542 – RHP, Landry Jurecka

While prepping this story, I took a look at many of the late-round draftpicks from around the league that I hadn’t really taken a look at prior to the draft. Jurecka was one that I saw and liked. Jurecka split time between starting and relieving (10 starts, 5 relief appearances) and finished with a 3.21 ERA, 1.298 WHIP, 9.4 SO/9 in the college season, and he also made three very strong starts in the summer Appalachian League where he gave up only 1 earned run across 14.0 innings.

#19.572 – RHP, Alabama, Braylon Myers

Myers was an undrafted player signed by the Cubs. He posted a 2.63 ERA, 1.000 WHIP, and 12.7 SO/9 in the SEC this year. Doesn’t have big present velo, but he can spin a breaking ball pretty well. If you can build him up to, even, 94-95mph; this could be a nice player.

#20.602 – CF, Dallas Baptist, Nathan Humphreys

One of the hardest cuts I had to make was pivoting off Seattle’s own pick of OF Korbyn Dickerson. I really like the potential for a power righthand bat that can stick in CF. Humphreys hits lefty, but otherwise has many of the same traits. He hit .353/.457/1.135 with 17 HR’s and 21 SB last year while playing elite defense. He went undrafted, so I have to guess at his signing bonus. I’ll just give him the max $150k.

All told, the top ten rounds of this draft class would have cost Seattle $16,482,900. Add to that an additional $584,000 from overslot deals in rounds 11-20; it brings the total cost of the bonus pool to $17,066,900 of the allowed $17,074,400. So I got it down to within $7500 of the bonus money. I kept it the same as Seattle in terms of pitchers to position players (13 to 8). I drafted a few more LHP than Seattle (5 to 3). I drafted a couple more high school players (4 to 2). From a position-player standpoint, I really only made one change where I drafted a 3B instead of a SS, but the SS in question was drafted in the 20th round and Scott Hunter was immediately talking about potentially converting him to a pitcher. And I even kept six of the exact same players as Seattle. Seattle drafted more guys that are 20-21 years old…I drafted more guys that are either 18 or 22 years old. I feel like this is a better balance than what Seattle actually did.

It will be fun to look back at this piece 3-4 years from now to see who actually had put together the better draft class.

Mariner mock revisions

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

As I’ve just been digging around for draft intel and data and any kind of potential edge prior to Sunday’s first night of the MLB Draft, it occurred to me that I’ve missed one type of process point in my prior mocks.

The MLB has set up a rule wherein the players that attend the MLB Draft Combine and submit to the physical portion of the process will be guaranteed to be paid at least 75% of the slot bonus for whichever pick they’re chosen at. This somewhat limits MLB teams’ option to pay these players “underslot” deals. This is primarily beneficial for the senior college players that would otherwise have little negotiating power after using up their college eligibility. This was, specifically, relevant for two players in my most recent mock that I am going to adjust for here.

I’m also saying fuck it to acknowledging what I think Seattle will do. This is my taste and my structure of how best to hack this draft class. Seattle is potentially going to draft for “need” to an extent. Nothing that the MLB team needs right now is going to come from this draft, nor is anything in this draft going to overtake what is already in the minor league system. If we want players that will affect the 2026 roster; we need to trade prospects for major league players. This mock is simply, in my opinion, the best way to pick the best future MLB roster.

#1.3 – SS, Corona HS, Billy Carlson

Seattle probably drafts one of the college LHP here, and that might be good for the eventual structure of their whole draft, but I just can’t get over how smooth and polished Carlson is with both the glove and the bat. He feels like one of the few guys at the top of this tepid draft top 10 that has true upside. He has so much body control…all we need is to see him get stronger and his pure current launch angle line drives will become homeruns.

Carlson is ranked #7 on the MLB board, so another part of the idea here is that we should sign him for under the $9.5mill bonus slot. I’ve budgeted him for $8mill.

#1.35cb – RHP, Louisville, Patrick Forbes

Forbes might be the key to this whole draft. If he’s still on the board at #35; I struggle to see the Mariner pitching lab not latching on to him, even though they could start trying to take overslot high school players here. I think I may have reached a new understanding of how Seattle scouts pitching, and if I’m right…Forbes will be a guy they covet.

Forbes has college eligibility remaining, so he will still require a decent signing bonus. I’m giving him slightly below the slot of $2.75mill with a bonus of $2.5mill.

#2.57 – LHP, Johnson HS, Johnny Slawinski

Part of the reason I’m passing on the college LHP at #3 is because I think, longterm, Slawinski will be better than them. The only reason he isn’t a bigger deal right now is because of velo. But, also, what a contradiction that the #1 college LHP, Kade Anderson, has gotten there because of pitchability over velo, and yet, somehow, guys like Kruz Schoolcraft and Jack Bauer are ranked higher (#19 and #44) on the prep lefty board than Slawinski (#68) who has the better pitchability of those three. Whatever. Market inefficiency that I’m hoping to exploit.

Seattle signed Ryan Sloan away from his college commitment at pick #2.55 last year, and a bonus of $3mill. I’m doing the exact same figure for Slawinski at #57…$3mill. This equates to a top 32 pick bonus.

#3.91 – OF, Purvis HS, Jacob Parker

I started including this half of the Parker twins in my last mock, and I’m going to keep him here. I had tinkered with some prep righthanded power hitters; but I was struggling to justify the swing and miss on most of those specific players.

Parker, on the other hand, has one of the strongest overall profiles in my database for this prep class. He’s underrated in a lot of facets, but certainly his power is unquestioned. I’m offering him an overslot bonus of $1.22mill.

#4.122 – RHP, UNCW, Zane Taylor

Taylor is one of the picks that I’ve had to adjust my drafting on. He is one of the guys that is a senior, but who is gonna be guaranteed at least 75% of the bonus for the slot where he’s picked. I’ve also moved him up a round because I think I had him underrated.

The slot for this pick is $617,200, so I’m giving him just over the 75% figure with a signing bonus of $465,000.

#5.152 – RHP, Baylor, Gabe Craig

In my previous mock, I had Seattle drafting Tennessee reliever Tanner Phillips who brings over a 100mph fastball and could move really fast to the show. Phillips is not a senior and would be guaranteed 75% of slot, so I just don’t know that I can afford him.

Craig is actually one of the highest-scoring pitchers in my entire 2025 college database. He is 24 years old and was not at the Draft Combine, so we can give him the full senior-sign treatment. Last year, Seattle used a couple of relievers (Hunter Cranton and Charlie Beilenson) to save bonus money in this same range of the draft. Those guys got $50k and $25k respectively. I’m not going that hard on Craig, and I can offer him $150k. This still saves Seattle ~$350k for other picks.

#6.182 – C, Wright State, Boston Smith

Smith is a longtime carryover from my previous mocks. He should be a true senior-sign player as a 22 year old who was not invited to the Combine.

As a lefthanded, power-hitting catcher that has good catch and throw tools; I’m super psyched to add him to the system.

#7.212 – RHP, Shawnee Mission HS, Michael Winter

Winter is a 6’5″/220lb pitcher coming out of Kansas with a really impressive present three-pitch mix. Similar to Slawinski; I love the pitchability more than the current velo. I think Seattle has struggled developing high school guys that come out of their senior year(s) with 97+ kind of velocity (Walter Ford comes to mind). I would like to try the opposite. Let’s draft guys that know how to pitch/spin and see if we can teach them to throw harder.

Winter has an unusual commitment to Dartmouth, but he did attend the Draft Combine, which may speak to an interest in signing if the price is right. I’m offering him $1.20mill, which correlates to approximately the #70 pick’s bonus.

#8.242 – LHP, Florida, Pierce Coppola

Coppola is a frequent returner to my mock drafts. I am adjusting his bonus to reflect his status as a guaranteed 75% senior from the Combine. I will give him $170k and work to come up with a program that can keep him healthy enough to continue to be a starter. If not…maybe he might thrive with a bullpen role.

#9.272 – RHP, Vanderbilt, Sawyer Hawks

Hawks is a return to the full-fledged senior-sign players. Another 22 year old, reliever-only, that was not at the Combine, we can sign him for basically whatever amount we want (and he agrees to). I’ve budgeted the very specific amount of $129,400.

#10.302 – 3B, Rhode Island, Anthony Depino

Depino falls, somewhat, victim to the MLB Draft rules that give very few options to a player of his age and the college he attended. He gets the smallest bonus of my top 10 rounds with only a $90k bonus.

#11.332 – LHP, Georgia, Alton Davis

The 11th round is frequently one of the more interesting picks in a Mariner draftclass. It’s the first pick of the draft that doesn’t count towards their overall bonus pool. There is no penalty for not signing the player drafted here, while simultaneously, there is more talent still on the board here, obviously, than the 12th-20th rounds. You can draft an overslot guy here if you think you have savings, while not being overly concerned that this pick will affect the others.

Davis is a bit of a wildcard. He has never performed to a level that gives him a high floor. He’s a pretty pure upside pick. You’re hoping you can take his 97mph fastball from the left side, and his plus slider, and you can get him to throw more strikes with them. In 2025 in the SEC, Davis got hit around more than 2023 Mariner 12th round pick, Logan Evans. But Seattle saw enough in Evans to get him figured out to the point he has made it to the show in under two years. Evans was primarily a starter for Pitt, whereas Davis has only really pitched out of the bullpen in college, but Alton has currently made three starts in the MLB Draft League, so maybe there is an outside chance he continues doing that.

The bonus for all picks in rounds 11-20 is slotted for $150k. Teams can go over that figure, but all overages count toward their top 10 round pool.

#12.362 – 1B, Loyola Marymount, Beau Ankeney

Most of the rest of this mock will match what I wrote last weekend. I’m not describing a specific bonus amount unless I expect the player to need overslot money.

#13.392 – OF, Youngstown St, Kyle Fossum

See previous mock.

#14.422 – 2B, UConn, Ryan Daniels

See previous mock.

#15.452 – RHP, Dax Dathe

In the days after my previous mock; a couple of things happened. I saw more video of Dax Dathe pitching in the MLB Draft League that looked pretty great, and my previous projected pick at #452, RHP Max Grubbs, announced that he is withdrawing his name from the draft to remain at Texas.

Cool. Easy one-for-one swap.

#16.482 – OF, Southern, Cardell Thibodeaux

See previous mock.

#17.512 – LHP, St Joseph, Colton Book

See previous mock.

#18.542 – C, Georgia State, Colin Hynek

See previous mock.

#19.572 – LHP, Northeastern, Jordan Gottesman

After going away from the mock with the college LHP in the top pick; I made a choice to hunt for lefthanded college starters whenever I could. Gottesman doesn’t have some of the pitch metrics I think Seattle looks for, but he’s certainly had pretty strong results in the 2025 season. Across 83 innings he finished with a 2.27 ERA, 0.864 WHIP, 10.5 SO/9 and 1.8 BB/9. Maybe the performance staff can build up his strength and/or flexibility in order to tap into a bit more upside.

#20.602 – CF, UTSA, Mason Lytle

See previous mock.

Mariner mock 3

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

We’re just over three weeks away from the 2025 MLB Draft, and things are speeding up in the process. The finals of the College World Series start tomorrow, and we’ve seen some high pressure, high stakes performances from many names relevant to this year’s draft. Multiple summer leagues are underway including the MLB Draft League and the Cape Cod League. And last week we had the fifth annual MLB Draft Combine. We’re getting lots of new, more specific data points on a lot of players hoping to hear their names called in July.

This new info is, perhaps, pointing us towards a clearer picture of the broader overall draftboard. What are the tiers of different player profiles. Who are the guys that are rising. Who are the guys at the back of the draft that have differentiated themselves from guys that will probably go undrafted.

In my previous mock draft for the Mariners; I speculated on a draft strategy wherein Seattle would look to, effectively, trade their 2025 first round pick at #3 overall to the 2026 draft where it would become the #4 overall pick, in what looks to be a stronger class at the top of the draft. I knew when I wrote that mock this idea was unlikely…nobody in MLB ever does this. I still think it would be a bold, innovative, and smart move. But it’s like a 1% chance that it happens.

So what would be the second-best draft strategy in a weak top-end draft class?? I think it would be to hyper-focus on prep players. The guys that we don’t have as clear of a picture on their future values, but which could mean higher upside (while, naturally, also having the risk of lower upside). While seeking that upside, I think it’s simultaneously important to get multiple bites at that apple, which means looking for an underslot signer for that #3 pick (and maybe a couple select points on day two of the draft), which can then give you surplus bonus money to offer to players that fall to later picks.

Something that the media has come to pretty consensus agreement on for this draft class is that there is a pretty strong group of high school shortstops. This group includes to some degree, and some variance in likelihood that they can stick at short, players like: Ethan Holliday, Eli Willits, Billy Carlson, Jojo Parker, Steele Hall, and Daniel Pierce. These are all players ranked in the top 20 overall on most big boards.

Holliday is widely considered to be the likely #1 pick going to the Washington Nationals. We won’t look much at him.

Willits is the #5 player on the MLB board. Listed 6’1″/180lbs and a switch-hitter. Willits is a young player for the class (which some teams prefer) as he won’t turn 18 until December.

Carlson is #7 on the MLB board. Listed 6’1″/185lbs and a righthanded hitter. Carlson will turn 19 about two weeks after the draft. He might be the best pure defender amongst these early candidates.

Parker is #10 on the MLB board. Listed 6’2″/200lbs and hitting lefthanded. Parker probably has the best hit-tool amongst this group, while probably having the least likelihood of sticking at short. He turns 19 in August. Of this group, Parker is the one that two separate media sources have independently connected to Seattle as a potential underslot signee.

Hall is the #13 player on the MLB board. Listed 6’0″/180lbs and hitting righty. Hall is another younger player that will turn 18 about ten days after the draft. Interestingly, Hall and Billy Carlson are both committed to the University of Tennessee. It’s unlikely both make it to Knoxville.

Pierce is the #18 overall on teh MLB board. Listed 6’0″/185lbs and hitting righthanded. He will turn 19 in August.

Is there a combination of present grade, future grade, and signing bonus figure from this group that puts one of these guys ahead of the others? And, really, part of the equation is actually: “is it better to draft a college player at/near/above bonus slot at #3, or would it be better to get an underslot player with more upside that then also allows you to get another upside player later on?” Basically a question of, “can you get two for one?”

In this particular draft class, I think they should do the latter. Let’s go for the 2×1.

In my opinion, the two guys to focus on in this scenario are Billy Carlson and Jojo Parker. This basically represents the best defender of the group and the best hitter of the group. In my first mock draft in May, I actually was going with Carlson as I just loved his glove so much. In theory, Seattle has two pretty strong shortstop candidates already coming through the system in Colt Emerson and Felnin Celesten. We don’t, necessarily, HAVE to keep a guy at shortstop.

So, in this mock, I’m pivoting to take the better hitter, who also happens to be the guy that has some buzz surrounding Seattle interest. There’s also the fact that Parker was a member of the 2024 East Coast Pro all star team of players from the states of Mississippi, Alabama, Arkansas, etc that were chosen by Mariner scouts and played under the name “Mariners”. There is some documented connection between Seattle and Jojo (and Jojo’s twin brother, Jacob).

#1.3 – SS, Purvis HS, Jojo Parker

While the hit-tool is clearly the headliner here; as I’ve dug in deeper to Parker I think his power and his glove are underrated. No, I don’t think he sticks at shortstop, but I do think he sticks on the dirt. His fielding actions are smooth and efficient. I think his move off shortstop will be dictated more by his range than his literally fielding. His arm looks decent. I think he’s a future third baseman. And that’s where the underrated power will come into play. I think his power is coming along very nicely and he will have enough power for 3B. He might end up similar to another player that has recently been in the news: Rafael Devers.

Now comes the business end of this selection. As a guy being projected as the #10 player in this class; if you draft him at #3, you’re doing so (in part) to save some money. The #3 pick holds a bonus slot value of $9.5million. The bonus slot value of, say, the #10 pick is $6.2million. The middle point between those two is $7.85million. If you sign Parker for, roughly, $8million, that $1.5million savings will come in extremely useful on later picks. For those that question the plausibility of underslotting a high school player at #3…Max Clark was drafted at #3 overall in 2023 and signed for about $600k underslot. The same draft, Blake Mitchell signed for ~$1.08million underslot at pick #8. Kumar Rocker drafted out of college in 2022 at pick #3 signed for $2.39mill underslot.

#1.35c – 3B/OF, Oaks Christian HS, Quentin Young

The second big adjustment in this mock draft is that my intended/previous target at #35, RHP Patrick Forbes, is now going to be off the board after his performance in the CWS. But, with the bonus savings at #3, this pick can now be another prep player.

I love 2B/OF Sean Gamble. What an impressive, mature profile. He kind of reminds me of Corbin Carroll.

I love local product Xavier Neyens, but as a lefthanded hitter with future 3B in his projection; he’s probably redundant after drafting Parker.

And there’s potentially a handful of prep pitchers that profile similar to 2024 draftee Ryan Sloan that might fit here: LHP Jack Bauer, RHP Aaron Watson, RHP Landon Harmon, LHP Johnny Slawinski. High school arms are historically the riskiest draft demographic, and Seattle historically can find/develop interesting, future-MLB arms from college pitchers in the midrounds of the draft.

I’m going with Quentin Young here because he’s different than what we’ve ever seen the M’s draft out of high school. He’s a power-first righthanded hitter when Seattle has almost always drafted hit-first, lefthanded guys.

Young is an MLB bloodline guy with two uncles that played in Delmon and Dmitri Young. He’s already 6’6″/225lbs with grown-man exit velocities touching 115mph at this week’s Combine. He’s got pretty surprising fluidity playing the infield at that size, so he might stick there. But he’s also got enough speed when underway that he might make a decent outfielder.

Quentin is ranked #33 overall on the MLB board, so this isn’t a reach or a fall. And then it comes down to giving him enough bonus to sign him away from college commitment to LSU. The slot value for #35 is $2.75mill. With most of the savings from the #3 pick; we could get Young signed for $4mill, which equates to about the #21 overall pick, aka first round money.

#2.57 – LHP, Iowa, Cade Obermueller

If there’s a second category of player that the 2025 draft looks especially strong in; it’s probably lefthanded pitching. And that is something that Seattle is woefully short on in their farm and major league team. I don’t know why they treat LHP the way that they do. I speculate they have data that points to RHP being stronger performers in TMobile Park, but who knows.

There’s also something interesting going on this year with pitchers that are shorter in stature. There are an unusually high number of starting pitchers that are right about 6’0″ tall. Liam Doyle is listed 6’2″ but I don’t believe that at all. JB Middleton is listed 6’0″, Gage Wood is listed 6’0″, Obermueller is listed 6’0″, JD Thompson is listed 6’0″, Brian Curley is listed 5’10”, Zane Taylor is listed 6’0″. Could there be a Spencer Strider in that group?

Obermueller might be merging these two factions. For the year, he posted a 3.02 ERA, 1.128 WHIP, 12.6 SO/9, 3.5 BB/9. Compare that to likely top five pick Jamie Arnold: 2.98 ERA, 1.063 WHIP, 12.6 SO/9, 2.9 BB/9. And then note the similar pitching mechanics/release heights of these two players. These are surprisingly similar profiles, but with a huge discount on Cade.

#3.91 – OF, George Mason, James Quinn-Irons

There’s a nice little pocket of players in this class that have imposing size, nice power, sneaky good gloves, and bonus basestealing in the outfield. I like JQI the best of that grouping. Listed 6’5″/230lbs and posting a 2025 line of: .419/.523/1.258, with 16 HR, 42 XBH, 39 BB, 46 SO.

#4.122 – RHP, Tulane, Michael Lombardi

After losing out on Patrick Forbes, I think I’ve found a similar profile in Lombardi. Forbes was formerly a two-way player that is now pitching-only for the last two years. Lombardi was still playing two-ways this year with games as CF, 2B, 1B and P (primarily CF).

As a pitcher, Lombardi had 23 appearances, including 6 games started. I don’t have splits for how his numbers broke down starter vs reliever, but his overall performance went: 2.14 ERA, 0.976 WHIP, 15.6 SO/9, 4.5 BB/9 across 42 innings. The hope is that he can start and that, with focus on pitching, he can tighten up his control.

#5.152 – C, Wright State, Boston Smith

I think I’ve bounced back and forth in my respective mocks on how early to draft Smith. I’m steering into my hitting metric this time, and giving him closer to the value that my stat suggests. The lefty-hitting catcher with power is just too valuable.

#6.182 – RHP, UNCW, Zane Taylor

Similar to Boston Smith, with Taylor I’m steering into my pitching metric more this time. Taylor is another in that list of shorter starting pitchers that we’re dreaming on a Spencer Strider. On the year, Taylor went 1.98 ERA, 0.763 WHIP, 9.9 SO/9, 1.0 BB/9. At the combine he posted one of the top fastball velo’s at 97.7mph.

#7.212 – RHP, Abilene Christian, Dominick Reid

Reid I had in my previous mock. 6’3″/201lbs and a former transfer from Oklahoma State. Reid’s line was 3.26 ERA, 1.109 WHIP, 11.4 SO/9, 2.8 BB/9 in 15 starts this year. And then, at the Combine this week, Reid popped as one of the top performers in multiple pitch movement measurements. There’s some intriguing clay to mold here.

#8.242 – 3B, Cincinnati, Kerrington Cross

Most likely a senior sign, Cross has tremendous intangibles, and he’s no slouch in the on-field performance: .396/.526/1.173, 12 HR, 50 BB, 35 SO, 15 SB.

#9.272 – RHP, Baylor, Gabe Craig

Craig is the #1 relief pitcher in my metric, and he has some postseason awards on his resume that may make this way too late to get him. But at 6’5″/209lbs, with a 0.56 ERA, 0.500 WHIP, 14.3 SO/9, 0.8 BB/9 and 10 saves this could be a fast-mover in a system that needs more in-house pitching.

#10.302 – OF, Dallas Baptist, Nathan Humphreys

Humphreys first caught my eye with his glove. He’s got legit centerfield skills. And then his offensive line wasn’t too shabby either. He hit .353/.457/1.135 with 17 HR, 38 BB, 38 SO, and 21 SB.

#11.332 – LHP, Florida, Pierce Coppola

Coppola is a carryover from previous mocks, and we’re just trying to find the sweet spot between his present value where he’s a frequently-injured starting pitcher, his really strong performance when he HAS pitched, and the fact that he might be discounted due to his senior status (and injury history). But if you pick the right round, this could be insane value for an SEC starter.

#12.362 – RF, Kent State, Jake Casey

Casey is the son of Sean, the longtime MLB player, and he has put together a very solid college career in his own right. At 6’2″/190lbs, Sean hit .356/.500/1.236 with 17 HR, 20 SB last year. And he’s got an above-average outfield arm.

#13.392 – RHP, Vanderbilt, Sawyer Hawks

It felt like the Mariners tried to draft a handful of quick-moving, relief pitchers in the 2024 Draft. That effort seemed to sidetrack this year with injuries and/or underperformance. But it still could be a useful strategy going forward. Hawks is an Air Force Academy transfer listed 6’4″/215lbs. In 2025 he had a 1.60 ERA, 0.800 WHIP, 11.8 SO/9, 2.2 BB/9 and 8 saves in 18 appearances out of the Vandy bullpen. His fastball has been up to 95mph.

#14.422 – 1B, Austin Peay, Ray Velazquez

There were a bunch of interesting bats on this Austin Peay roster, but I came away having Velazquez as the highest on my hitting metric. At 6’1″/212lbs he hit .364/.479/1.207 with 18 HR, 32 BB, 32 SO in the college season, and he’s continued swinging it well across the first five games he’s played on the Cape where he’s sitting at a .389 average.

#15.452 – RHP, Coastal Carolina, Ryan Lynch

Lynch is the local product from Monroe, WA that has made his way all the way to the College World Series finals tomorrow. A pure reliever at 6’4″/234lbs, he has a 0.58 ERA, 1.032 WHIP, 10.2 SO/9, 2.9 BB/9 and 9 saves in 27 appearances.

#16.482 – 2B, UConn, Ryan Daniels

When doing a Mariner mock draft, I can’t help but think of it similarly to putting together a roster. After all, most of these guys will end up becoming the bulk of the low-A Modesto lineup later this summer. You kind of need a variety of guys so that you have most positions covered.

Daniels was one of the better second base options from my hitting metric. He posted a line of .365/.476/1.220 this year with 18 HR, 40 BB, 41 SO, and 10 SB for the Huskies.

#17.512 – LHP, UCSB, Hudson Barrett

Barrett was one of my most recent discoveries just in the last week after popping in the Combine with some of the higher-ranking pitch movement statistics on his secondary pitches. At 6’5″/225lbs, Hudson is a prototypical pitcher build, and his rate stats of 1.93 ERA, 0.643 WHIP, 9.6 SO/9 are solid. There is some question mark as to why he only threw 4.2 innings during the college season in three starts as an “opener”. In his summer league more recently, Barrett threw 4.0 innings of shutout ball.

#18.542 – C, Georgia State, Colin Hynek

I generally like to have two catchers in every mock. It’s too much of a specialty position to not get a couple. Hynek is a 6’1″/200lb backstop with an underwhelming .230/.396/.982 slash, but 18 HR and a solid catch and throw defensive profile.

#19.572 – RHP, Grove City CC, David Leslie

Leslie is another recent discovery after a strong performance in his first appearance out of the bullpen for his MLB Draft League team. Listed 6’3″/185lbs, his JUCO season line went: 2.05 ERA, 0.938 WHIP, 10.13 SO/9.

#20.602 – LF, Southern, Cardell Thibodeaux

Thibodeaux is quietly one of the best pure hitters in the country. He hit .439/.544/1.391 with 18 HR, 39 BB, 27 SO, and 24 SB during the college regular season, and he’s recently posting near-identical numbers in the Draft league at .423/.545/1.199 with 1 HR, 7 BB, 4 SO in 7 games so far. The downside is that he’s only 5’8″/175lbs and really only has one year of strong performance, and it came in the lower level Southwestern Athletic Conference.

Mariners mock draft

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

The MLB Draft is less than two months away, taking place this year July 13th-15th and this could, not unlike the 2025 Seahawk draft, become an organization-changing draft. The change began months ago when Seattle moved up from the 15th overall pick to the third overall pick in the draft thanks to the draft lottery. In addition, Seattle was awarded pick #35 at the end of the first round in the “Competitive Balance round”. These two high selections, and the slotted draft bonus pool that comes with them, have put Seattle into the driver’s seat as the team in all of MLB with the biggest allotment of draft bonus pool.

The Mariners will enter the draft with $17,074,400 in bonus pool. This will mean tremendous flexibility in how they manipulate their selections in July. They will be able to buy out higher caliber, and/or more, of this year’s best high school players from their college commitments by creating bonus surplus with selective underslot picks/signings. This could mean a higher upside draft than we’ve seen in the Dipoto era.

Certainly, we will see the highest overall draftpick in the Dipoto era. The previous high pick was 2020 when Seattle drafted Emerson Hancock at #6 overall. And it ties the highest pick the Mariners have made since 2012 when they drafted Mike Zunino at #3.

Now, unfortunately, there is a downside. I think all of these draft windfalls might be coming at a pretty bad time in terms of the quality of the draft. I, personally, don’t really love this draft class. There is no Paul Skenes, no Travis Bazzana at the top of the class. I don’t love the consensus top three players in most mock drafts. The top prep hitter, Ethan Holliday, feels stiff and unselective. The top prep pitcher, Seth Hernandez, has mechanics that I really don’t like. The top college pitcher, Jamie Arnold, is my favorite of the three, but even him I have questions on.

I would love to see Seattle go sort of unexpected and take a mild reach on someone at #3, sign him for underslot, and then attack their next few picks for upside. I think this might be a draft you consider taking three high school players in your top four picks.

Seattle needs more pitching prospects. The M’s recently became MLB’s richest farm system with nine unique players on the top 100 list, but the top seven of their nine are all position players. The two pitchers recently added are their top two picks from the 2024 Draft, Jurrangelo Cijntje and Ryan Sloan, and are ranked #92 and #96 respectively.

They may force pitching pick(s) early and often this draft. But I wouldn’t necessarily do that.

For those concerned with giving underslot deals to a player at #3…that’s not really historically relevant. Travis Bazzana was signed for underslot at #1.1 last year and Paul Skenes was signed for underslot at #1.1 two years ago. Max Clark was signed for underslot as a high school draftee at pick #1.3 also in 2023. It’s actually easier, and therefore more common, to go underslot when you draft early because the slotted money starts so much higher.

#1.3 – SS, Corona High School, Billy Carlson

A high school teammate of Seth Hernandez, Carlson is arguably the best defensive shortstop in the draft. He’ll definitely stick at short going forward. And I think his bat is underrated. He’s got more power than he’s credited with, and there could be more coming as he gains strength. He’s currently listed at 6’1″/185lbs.

Carlson doesn’t have the profile of 2019 #2 overall draftpick Bobby Witt Jr who had a thicker build and MLB bloodlines, but I feel like Carlson has the makeup to become a guy that is a multi-year all star and Gold Glover in the vein of Witt, Gunnar Henderson, or (my closest comp) Dansby Swanson.

Carlson is committed to Tennessee and he’s the #6 player on the MLB.com big board. If you draft him at #3, where the slot bonus is $9,504,400, but sign him for a value of $8.5mill, a value somewhere between the 4th and 5th pick, you’ll have another $1mill for later picks.

#1.35.CB – RHP, Louisville, Patrick Forbes

This is a very interesting pick location. You could try to flip your bonus savings from the first pick to a prep player that has slid down the draft due to signability requirements, you could treat this pick like your first pick from 2024 when you draft the best college righthander available at slot, or you could reach on a guy with lower ranking on national boards and just give him the bonus value at 35 that would be called overslot at 57. I’m kinda going with the middle option with Forbes.

Forbes is a 6’3″/220lb righthanded pitcher that won’t be 21 until two days before the draft. He was a two-way player his freshman year at Louisville, and so he’s technically only been focusing exclusively on pitching the last two years, and it’s only been 2025 that he’s been exclusively a starting pitcher. So there’s some reason to believe that his statline this year hides the fact that there’s still growth/upside to unlock in him.

At present, Forbes has used a repertoire featuring a fastball that is up to 100mph, that really explodes up in the zone, and a nasty slider, to strikeout over 14.00 per nine. His third pitch, a changeup, still needs work and more frequent use to stay in the rotation. But, at minimum, he should have a floor as an elite reliever a la Matt Brash.

The bonus for this pick is $2,758,300, and I’m probably trying to get Forbes for $2.5mill of that due to his young age and college eligibility still left.

If Seattle goes high school again here for an overslot deal…I prefer the bats including local product Xavier Neyens from Mount Vernon, MLB-legacy player Quentin Young (nephew of Delmon and Dmitri), or Sean Gamble. Neyens is a big-power, lefty hitting 3B. Young is probably a 3B as well, but has some of the best prep power from the right side. And Gamble reminds me a bit of Corbin Carroll, and probably profiles as a future OF that hits from the left side.

#2.57 – LHP, Johnson HS, Johnny Slawinski

I love this draft throughout for lefthanded pitching. I hope Seattle comes away with 3-4 pretty intriguing southpaws in the top 10 rounds. Slawinski is probably my favorite lefty from the high school group. He’s not the velo king of the group, but I just love the clean mechanics and the pitchability. At 6’3″/180lbs, there’s enough frame to add some velo as he gets stronger.

The slot value for this pick is $1,636,800 and I definitely think we need to go overslot to get him away from his college commitment to Texas A&M. Last year, Seattle drafted Ryan Sloan, the #19 player on the MLB board, at pick #2.55 overall. They signed him for $3.00mill…well above the slot of $1.64mill. It might take a similar figure to get Slawinski secured. We have $1mill surplus from the first pick, so we’ll need another $363k savings from any of our later picks.

#3.91 – RHP, Corona HS, Ethin Bingaman

This is the first pick that is a little harder to predict. Historically, Seattle has used their third round pick on multiple occasions to save some bonus money to channel to their earlier picks. This year, however, after going underslot at #1.3, we might be able to target another prep player that is still available and give him overslot here. But just who that player might be is the hardest part to predict.

The bonus allotment for #91 is $851,800. Draft signees love some good, round numbers, so if we can bump that amount up to $1.0mill, we could get another upside prep player. Ethin Bingaman comes from the same high school team as Carlson and Hernandez (and Brady Ebel). He reminds me a bit of Patrick Forbes only three years earlier in his development. He’s currently a two-way player, but I’m going to take him as a pitcher. 6’1″/200lbs and with a fastball that presently touches 95mph with ride.

#4.122 – C, Texas, Rylan Galvan

I’m pretty intentional when I look for catchers in these baseball mock drafts, and Galvan fits pretty closely to what I’m looking for. Listed 6’0″/205lbs, and hitting .299/.453/1.088 on the year with 14 HR and 46 RBI. He will be 22 years old in June, so there may be some wiggle room for bonus. I’m underslotting him about $117k.

#5.152 – LHP, Florida, Pierce Coppola

Coppola is an interesting case. He’s a 6’8″/245lb lefty starter that shows up as the #1 pitcher in my analytic study that I do every draft cycle. The problem is the guy has only made 15 appearances across four college seasons since 2022. He made one start in 2022, missed all of 2023, made 8 starts in 2024, and he’s currently at 6 starts this year. Huge medical redflags.

But when he’s been healthy, he’s been one of the toughest AB’s a college hitter can face. So we’re taking a calculated gamble here that our pitching program can unlock some way(s) to either keep him healthy, or simply recreate him as a dominant long-reliever, maybe closer. And, obviously, due to the risk, we sign him for only $400k…$61k underslot.

#6.182 – LHP, St Joseph, Colton Book

Another college lefty, Colton Book is a bit harder to find video of, but he popped in my pitching study as one of the best values in the draft. At 6’4″/210lbs he certainly looks the part on paper. He’ll be 23 years old in August, so we get him with some senior savings (~$50k). This year he has posted a 3.20 ERA, 0.931 WHIP, 12.6 SO/9 line across 80+ innings. Signing bonus: $300k.

#7.212 – 3B, Austin Peay, Ray Velazquez

After studying about 100 of the top draft-eligible college hitters; Ray Velazquez came out as one of this year’s top 10. And there is some pedigree here, as Velazquez played for Vanderbilt in 2024. This year, he’s hitting .377/.487/1.261 with 18 HR and 57 RBI. Another slight underslot signing at $250k due to age (23 in September).

#8.242 – 2B/OF, Georgia, Robbie Burnett

I don’t have much reason for the order I’m mocking most of these guys past the top 150 picks, as most big boards available via the media don’t currently go beyond 150. I have no reference point for how the industry sees some of these players. I’ve only passively used the thought: I value catcher over third base, third base over second base, etc.

Burnett has been a very strong player for the Bulldogs this year, hitting .318/.492/1.224 with 20 HR, 66 RBI, and 17 SB. He has split time on defense between (in order): right field, second base, left field, center field.

These last three picks I’m back on track bonus-wise to allow each to receive exactly slot.

#9.272 – RHP, Indiana, Cole Gilley

Gilley is an over-aged (almost 24) righthander that has mixed between 11 starts and 6 relief appearances, and sports a combined 3.88 ERA, 1.101 WHIP, 10.5 SO/9 over 62.2 innings.

#10.302 – C, Wright State, Boston Smith

Boston Smith is another catcher that ticks most of the boxes I’m looking for, but in this case he brings the bonus attribute of hitting lefthanded. A smaller physical backstop, Smith is 5’10″/195lbs and has hit .322/.494/1.222 with 21 HR, 60 RBI, and 15 SB.

Mariner draft week mock

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

We’re down to four days before the beginning of the 2024 MLB Draft, and I’m probably not going to have much time to do long-form writing the closer we get. So this is probably my last chance to get a full-mock update in.

Mariners’ scouting director Scott Hunter had a little press huddle sometime last week in which he gave some thoughts on the state of this draft class. A lot of what he said we already knew: there’s maybe 10 top of the first round locks (I put it at 12), which means starting around #11-13 we’re into a second tier of players, which surely affects Seattle at #15.

In my mock last week I pivoted to an underslot player in the 1st, to allow for buying overslot names rounds 2-5, and Hunter discussed (unprompted) that this might be a thing for Seattle this year.

He also talked about high school pitching. I think the greater press’ take that his thoughts point to the M’s drafting a prep pitcher in the 1st round is mistaken. I don’t think that’s really what he said, and it’s not what this draft class allows for. There are maybe four HS pitchers with first round projection, only three of which will probably still be available when Seattle is on the clock. That isn’t the way to hack this draft. Hunter specifically talks about prep pitching available from the back half of the first round through the 50’s…to me, this means from pick #16 to pick #59. This means it misses Seattle at #15, but is very much in play for Seattle at their second round pick at #55. This part I buy.

And if you look at mlb’s draft board, they have HS pitchers listed top 15 like this:

15- LHP Cam Caminiti

After the top 15 overall, they have prep pitchers listed like this:

16- RHP William Schmidt
19- RHP Ryan Sloan
30- LHP Kash Mayfield
36- RHP Braylon Doughty
41- LHP David Shields
46- RHP Joey Oakie
51- RHP Bryce Meccage
52- LHP Dasan Hill
56- RHP Dax Whitney
57- LHP Boston Bateman
58- RHP Levi Sterling
59- RHP Chris Levonas

See what I mean? One in the top 15. Two from 16-30. Two from 31-45. SEVEN from 46-60, including four after M’s pick at #55. This tracks.

#1.15 – RHP, LSU, Luke Holman

I opened with Holman last week, and I’m sticking with him to head into the draft. In fact, I found a piece of data in the last few days that only reaffirms my plan: Holman is primarily thought of as a 92-94mph fastball guy, but in 2023 when he was pitching for Alabama, a prominent college baseball outlet published that he touched 98mph. His mix of present stuff, 6’4″/201lb frame, and a history of touching higher velocity in SEC play, leads me to believe he’s gonna to tick up in the not-so-distant future.

And my previously stated plans to sign Holman, the #45 overall player, to an underslot bonus deal at #15, still holds. I did do some research on underslot deals in the 2023 draft, and it was rare to find discounts of over $1mill, like I had hoped. Brock Wilken signed for about -$871k underslot as the #18 overall pick, but for the most part deals were closer to $600k underslot. The slot at #15 is $4,880,900. If we can get Holman for $4mill even…awesome, but I think $4.2mill might be more realistic. Still, that would pocket us $680,900 for future picks.

#2.55 – RHP, Blackfoot HS, Dax Whitney

This is, obviously, the big change from last mock. I was previously thinking of a college bat in the 2nd round like when they got Tyler Locklear in 2022. But, really, in 2022 Seattle had two picks in the 2nd, and the other ended up being prep RHP Walter Ford.

Whitney is a pretty late-riser in this cycle as a guy coming from the rarely-scouted baseball state of Idaho. But he’s a 6’5″/193lb righty with a present fastball sitting 94mph, but touching 96. Adding muscle to his long, lean frame should really help him bump that up to closer to a 97mph regular velo, that can touch 99. He has two current secondaries that are pretty legit, and is working on his changeup to eventually give him a true four-pitch mix.

Whitney has a college commitment to Oregon State. The bonus slot for #55 is $1,641,800. Last year, Cleveland signed Alex Clemmey away from college for $2.3mill at pick #58, and Pittsburgh got Zander Mueth signed for $1.8mill at pick #67. In 2022, the Cubs needed $3.01mill to secure Jackson Ferris at pick #47 as the high end, but other prep pitchers signing that year included: 46- Jacob Miller ($1.70mill), 50- Jackson Cox ($1.85mill), 57- Cole Phillips ($1.50mill), 74- Walter Ford ($1.25mill). I think we should be able to get Whitney away from OSU for $2mill, which would be $358,200 overslot. Running total gives us $322,700 savings.

#3.91 – LHP, IMG Academy, Blake Larson

While doing diligence to see if there are any other prep LHP that I really like (after Caminiti), I came upon Larson in the last few days. I hadn’t watched him before that, but he’s 6’3″/180lbs with a present fastball touching 96mph with run. There is a very legit, high-spin slider as secondary offering, and he’s working on a change as third offering. I love the stuff, it’s more a question of: can he get more refined, and lock in better control as he matures?

Larson has a college commitment to TCU. He played his junior year of high school in Iowa, but this year he moved down to Florida and the prestigious IMG Academy on the cusp of the draft. Why would you make a huge geographic move in your senior year of high school for any reason other than increasing your draft profile? Meaning: you want to be drafted and you want to sign. The M’s bonus allotment for this pick is $812,900. I’m going to use all of my savings so far, and dip into some future money, to get Blake up to a $1.2mill bonus. We’re now $64,400 in the hole.

#4.121 – 1B/DH, Georgia, Corey Collins

Collins is one of the best hitters in this class. MLB has him as a 5th-6th round player…likely because, even though he has history of playing catcher and outfield in college, he’s limited to 1B/DH going forward. So, I’m hoping to steal him here in the 4th and create a nice, high-floor base for the M’s 2024 hitting class. Collins is also almost 23 years old, so he should be signable to an underslot deal. I’m hoping for $500k, which would save an additional $94,900. Current savings: $535,600.

#5.154 – RHP, Mississippi State, Nate Dohm

It’s an intended strategy to take pitching earlier than hitting in this draft. A) The Seattle farm is stronger on bats at the moment, B) the way this draft stacks up, the most projectable bats are either in the top 20 overall, or available after the 10th round. So, in theory, we should be able to pay premium prices on arms, and then circle back to bats later-ish. And it’s not unheard of for Seattle to do this. In 2019 they drafted five consecutive pitchers to start the draft, and eight of their first nine as pitchers. Five of those eight arms have made it all the way to MLB.

Dohm, like the pitching version of Collins, has some of the best pitching metrics in this draft for me versus SEC competition. There are some questions about health, which led to only 29.1 innings pitched this year. But I love the frame, I love the stuff, and I love the control. He’s 21 years old with eligibility remaining, but hopefully a full-slot deal here in the 5th gets him signed.

#6.183 – OF, Austin Peay, Lyle Miller Green

I’ve had LMG in prior mocks, and usually in later rounds, but I’m placing him earlier in this one because his talent warrants it, and because I currently need a senior signing to get back in the black for overall bonus money. We’ll call it a $125k bonus. We are now back to $139k underslot overall.

#7.213 – RHP, Kansas, Hunter Cranton

More senior signings. Cranton is a pure reliever with a fastball that is already 98mph and has awesome metrics, to go with another plus pitch in his slider. Already 23 years old, but you’ll see this repeatedly in this draft class due to being at the back end of the Covid class. Relievers, especially, with this kind of present stuff should move really quickly through the minors. Another $125k bonus senior signing.

#8.243 – MIF, Austin Peay, Jon Jon Gazdar

Gazdar has a pretty high-floor profile for another senior sign candidate. Primarily a shortstop in college, his profile probably moves him to 2B as a pro. Third consecutive $125k signing gives us $364k in underslot savings.

I’ve sort of earmarked the 9th round to be an overslot pick. I don’t know if it’s a highschool player, but it might be. There are definitely two college relievers with multiple years of eligibility remaining that I’m eying here. Actually, as I’m writing this, I’m wondering if I split the difference on the bonus surplus I have; could I get both of my guys in the 9th and 10th? Let’s try it.

#9.273 – RHP, Miami, Brian Walters

Walters is recently returned from Tommy John surgery, but came back with pretty impressive results posting a 1.024 WHIP, 14.5 SO/9 and only 1.3 BB/9 in 13.2 innings pitched in relief. Giving him even split of the bonus surplus remaining means he gets $418,450.

#10.303 – LHP, Rutgers, Donovan Zsak

Zsak is a returning entrant in my mock drafts who I’ve been over-drafting his draft projection due to the fact he’s technically a redshirt sophomore after missing 2023 with an injury. But he’s draft eligible at 21 years old. I had been planning, in previous mocks, to get him around 4th-6th round where the slot bonus ranges from $594k down to $334k, with the idea of giving him $400k at whichever round he ended up. The $418k I have left is perfect.

Zsak made 6 starts this year across his work at Rutgers and two made in the Cape league, in addition to 15 appearances in relief. I’d love to try him as a starter for as long as possible, knowing that his stuff will definitely tick up if we move him back to the pen as means to get him to the show faster.

#11.333 – RHP, Oregon State, Jacob Kmatz

Picks 11 and 12 of this mock I’m going away from pure stuff and looking for high-pitchability, innings-eaters. Kmatz presently maxes out about 93mph, but he knows how to maximize it up in the zone, and he has one of the prettiest curveballs I’ve seen in the class. And he controls it beautifully.

#12.363 – LHP, Oklahoma State, Sam Garcia

Garcia, again, doesn’t wow you with velo, but he’s doing enough with pitch sequencing and control, that he managed 11.6 SO/9 in his first year pitching for a Power 5 school. He’s got a big 6’4″/218lb frame, too, that lets you dream on more velo down the road.

#13.393 – OF, Evansville, Mark Shallenberger

Part of my strategy in this draft is to stock up on arms early, and find those sneaky hitters in late rounds (and undrafted free agency…which should be deep this year) that are probably small-school, but have great hit metrics (think in terms of Ben Williamson, Brock Rodden, etc). Shallenberger is at the top of that list. He reminds me a bit of Hunter Pence in that nothing he does is super fluid, and maybe you even go as far as to say “awkward”, but he’s a gamer. He hit .375/.514/1.201 with 17 HR, 64 RBI, and 45 BB to 28 SO.

#14.423 – 3B, NC State, Alec Makarewicz

Makarewicz is a senior of almost 24 years old, but he hit .378/.438/1.191 with 24 HR, 84 RBI with premiere exit velocity and a penchant for clutch hitting in the CWS. He plays a very solid defensive 3B, as well, and he can switch-hit.

#15.453 – 1B, Morehead St, Roman Kuntz

The Seattle farm is chock full of middle-infield potential thanks to multiple years of drafting there early and often, so I’m looking to take multiple stabs this draft at the corners of the infield. Kuntz is listed at 6’3″/180lbs, but looks way bigger on tape. Already a 23-year-old this March; Roman hit .366/.482/1.341 with 33 HR, 100 RBI, and 50 BB to 34 SO.

#16.483 – LHP, Oklahoma St, Ryan Ure

This is a pure velo play. Ure has a ton of redflags with injury history and lack of control, but he’s been up to 103mph from the left side. Well worth the risk this late, and it’s very likely another team has risked it earlier.

#17.513 – RHP, Arizona, Dawson Netz

Netz is a guy that really caught my eye in the recent MLB Draft League. At Arizona this year he was 4.29 ERA, 1.143 WHIP, 11.6 SO/9, but in the draft league he’s ticked up to 3.45 ERA, 0.894 WHIP, 14.4 SO/9. The breaking ball is pretty special.

#18.543 – RHP, William & Mary, Carter Lovasz

I found Lovasz just doing diligence on relievers. He’s got a good frame at 6’3″/185lbs, and I don’t have numbers on his present velo, but he’s definitely using it well up in the zone to the tune of 3.12 ERA, 1.154 WHIP, 11.8 SO/9 with 7 saves last year.

#19.573 – C, James Madison, Jason Schiavone

If there’s one thing in this draft that I wanted to do, but that the player pool really didn’t convince me to do, was to draft one or two higher end catchers. I still think Harry Ford ends up traded before the deadline, and there’s not a ton of talent in the farm. I wanted to find a catcher that has some power, has some defense, has some athleticism. Schiavone ticks a lot of that. He hit .284/.400/1.020 with 18 HR, 9 SB, and a 38% caught stealing rate. Yeah, that’ll do.

#20.603 – SS, Murray St, Drew Vogel

This pick could really be anything. I’ve got a first baseman in Tyler Macgregor I really like. I’ve got an outfielder named Ryley Preece that I think has some nice tools. I went with Vogel because he’s got good power at a premium defensive position. He hit .331/.441/1.097 with 20 HR, 61 RBI, and 16 SB.

I kinda recognize that this draft feels counter-intuitive to the state of the Mariners. But, really, the state of the MLB team and the state of the farm system are not the same. Whereas, the MLB roster is at a massive deficit on hitting, and the star of the show is our big league pitching…it’s pretty opposite on the farm. There is quite a deficit of pitching. We have a few starters that are out-performing draft position, with a few more that have been on longterm IL, but we have next to nothing exciting or MLB-quality coming out of our respective bullpens. And we’ve been getting decent early returns on middle-round college bats (Locklear, Williamson, Rodden, Schreck, which would work really well with this draft class.

This draft, more than any recent draft, is so dependent on how Seattle manages their first pick. If they can do something smart, and strategic, with that pick; they could be en route to a very interesting class.

Mariner mock July

/ seattleseamocks

By Jared Stanger

As I’m writing this on Sunday, June 30th; the MLB Draft round one will begin two weeks from today. There’s been an ongoing theme of this draft cycle for at least a month now that Seattle, drafting at #15 overall, is going to miss out on the true 1st round talents of this draft, which is only about 12 players deep. I’ve been doing mocks as if one of those guys will (miraculously) fall to them. Maybe that will happen, but I’m feeling more and more anxious that it won’t. So this mock represents my big pivot to a more plausible scenario.

The top 12 names go, in no order: Travis Bazzana, Charlie Condon, Jac Caglianone, Braden Montgomery, Nick Kurtz, JJ Wetherholt, James Tibbs, Konnor Griffin, Hagen Smith, Chase Burns, Trey Yesavage, Cam Caminiti. If any of these guys is available at #15; you just don’t think about it, and you take him. We need guys like Bryce Rainer, Christian Moore, and maybe like a Seaver King to be the “upsets” in the top 14 to get a 12 to us.

The more I’ve settled into the likely outcome that a top 12 fall doesn’t happen, the more I’ve come to think that maybe the hack of this draft for Seattle is: to accept they aren’t getting a “1st round talent”, and pivot to an idea that the next tier of names is like 30 players deep of a very similar grade, and to draft one that will allow you to backlog some significant slot bonus money by signing an underslot deal, which then allows them to try to make moves on bigger talents on day two.

When Seattle acquired Gregory Santos from the White Sox, part of the package going to Chicago was the #68 overall pick, which carries a bonus pool allotment of $1,197,200. I look at that figure and think that’s kind of the minimum amount I’d like to try to save in any combo of 1st-2nd round signings, and siphon that to day-two picks.

Looking at Seattle’s draft history under Jerry Dipoto…they have been ELITE at drafting and developing college pitching to completion as MLB players. They have NEVER graduated a high school pitcher from prospect to their own successful pro player, and they don’t even have any candidates currently above high-A level (*edit: as I was writing this, the news broke that 2021 high school 3rd rounder Michael Morales was promoted to AA), so they are at best extremely slow at developing them. The report card is still incomplete on how successful they’ve been drafting and developing prep hitters through the farm, but with Harry Ford and Cole Young doing decent at AA, plus promising early returns on Colt Emerson, Jonny Farmelo, Tai Peete, Aidan Smith…I don’t think you’d hesitate if the right guy was there. Perhaps the second-best draft/develop category for Seattle has been college hitters with Evan White winning an MLB Gold Glove, Kyle Lewis winning ROY, Cal Raleigh being the best power-hitting catcher in baseball, and MLB at-bats from Cade Marlowe, Austin Shenton (for Tampa), Zach Deloach (for CHW), and now Tyler Locklear. These are things you HAVE to consider if you’re Jerry and Scott Hunter. Self-scout.

The current media buzz on Seattle’s interest(s) at #15 is basically useless. Jim Callis, in his mock from last week, has Seattle drafting college switch-pitcher Jurrangelo Cijntje. He specifies, “the Mariners would like to restock their pitching supply”…awesome, they do need to do that. Callis continues, “(Trey) Yesavage is the dream here”…great, he’s pitcher 3 of 3 on my board, no complaints. He mentions Cam Caminiti before Cijntje, but Cam is off the board at #13 to San Francisco, which is one of the most consistent mock picks I see across all drafts. BUTTTT….in his mock from June 6th, Callis had Seattle drafting college 3B Cam Smith, but M’s are quote, “pursuing every demographic.”

Local writer that I really enjoy, Joe Doyle, on May 28 had Seattle draft prep LHP Kash Mayfield, and writes that, for Seattle, “it seems to be pitching, pitching, pitching.” Jump forward to June 25th, Boyle pivots to prep athlete Theo Gillen as his pick at #15, and his quote is, “Seattle seems to prefer college performers at this spot.”

There’s a lot of contradiction and inconsistency there at first blush. But, if you really break it down…Callis’ two most recent projections are 1) college pitcher, 2) “every demographic”. Doyle’s two theories are 1) pitching, 2) college. You can actually, potentially, draw a through-line there that becomes a college pitcher. Kinda interesting.

1.15 – RHP, Louisiana State, Luke Holman

If I remember correctly, I had Holman in my first mock of the year. That was when he was at the apex of his buzz this year. That faded a bit as the season progressed, but he’s landed at #45 overall. Just for reference, the other names mentioned by national media in mocks and their MLB rankings: #14 Cam Smith, #19 Ryan Sloan, #25 Cijntje, #27 Slade Caldwell, #28 Gillen, #30 Mayfield. I mean, Seattle is probably reaching on their pick at #15. Why not get a discount on that reach?

Holman ranks as a top-10 pitcher in this class in my pitching metric. He’s not as hot of a name as Hagen and Chase because those guys throw 99mph and struck out 17 per nine each and showed great control. Valid. He’s also not as hot a buzz as guys like Cijntje and Brody Brecht as well, but they only seem to be ranked higher than Holman because of velo. Not valid. I think their projectability is actually less than his.

Holman is a 6’4″/201lb starter that presently touches 94mph. So he’s not starting from that bad of a place velo-wise. And the frame is great to add some strength in time. There’s a decent amount of pitchers, like Degrom or Cole, that win Cy Young’s with elite velo. But there’s this entire pocket of guys that do it with control, secondaries, and pitchability. Scherzer at the high end, but I’m also looking at Shane Bieber and, especially, Corbin Burnes.

Burnes was a 6’3″/245lb starter when he came out of St Mary’s in the 2016 Draft. His fastball was in the 92-95 range and MLB ranked him the #39 prospect pre-draft, and he fell to the Brewers at #111 overall in the early 4th round. His stat line in his last year in college ran: 2.48 ERA, 1.072 WHIP, 10.6 SO/9, 3.64 SO/BB. Luke Holman this year at LSU: 2.75 ERA, 0.982 WHIP, 12.5 SO/9, 3.85 SO/BB. I like this profile more than the national media. If you don’t think you can get him at #55; I kinda don’t mind doing this at #15 with the underslot caveat.

Bonus slot for the #15 pick is $4,880,900. Bonus value at #45 (where Holman is projected) is only $2,072,800. If you split the difference, you’re at $3,476,850…call it $3.5mill, and you’ve pocketed $1,380,900 for future use.

Backup plan: similar story, but I like going underslot on prep RHP Joey Oakie. He’s literally next on MLB’s big board behind Holman at #46. Something about his mechanics and stuff reminds me of Bryan Woo. I think $3.5mill would get him out of his commitment to Iowa U.

2.55 – 1B/C, Georgia, Corey Collins

This pick, to me, is so similar to the pick of Tyler Locklear at 2.58 in 2022. Super advanced hit metrics but dragged down big boards by his, presumed, defensive positional limitations. But when you dig into his full profile…he’s not too far removed from being a left-handed hitting catcher (2 starts at C in 2024, 13 starts in 2023). He’s also been athletic enough at 6’3″/236lbs to play 20 games in the outfield in his Georgia career.

But the carrying tool is the bat. He hit LEADOFF for the Bulldogs for most of the year to the tune of .354/.574/1.346, 20 HR, 58 RBI, 56 BB, 32 SO. The RBI number probably would have been higher if he wasn’t hitting leadoff. By comparison, Player X in college: .374/.469/1.128, 14 HR, 60 RBI. That’s Pete Alonso.

In theory, this is a guy that would move fast through the minors as a 1B/DH. Could he debut straight out of spring training in 2026? Just as the contract for Mitch Garver is over and not renewed.

This pick is also somewhat reminiscent of the 2nd round pick of Ben Williamson last year, in that Williamson was drafted at #2.57 overall as a 22-year-old Senior, who signed for -$836,500 underslot. Collins is a 22-year-old Senior, and the bonus slot at #55 is $1,641,800. Coming from an SEC school, I don’t know that you underslot him down to $600k like they did for Williamson, but keeping him at a $1.2mill bonus would still save you $400k+ to use on day two.

These first two picks have saved Seattle a combined $1,822,700 of bonus pool.

Backup plan: any number of slight reaches on college pitchers like RHP Daniel Eagen, LHP Ryan Prager, RHP Ryan Forcucci who score very high on the pitch projection metric.

3.91 – RHP, Mississippi State, Nate Dohm

In 2023 Seattle drafted Tommy John patient and Wake Forest RHP Teddy McGraw at #3.92. They signed him for $136k underslot. Dohm is not currently recovering from TJ, but he was limited in 2024 to only 29.1 innings due to some kind of injury recovery/management.

When healthy, Dohm is up to 98mph with a 1.23 ERA, 0.920 WHIP, 11.4 SO/9 and only 1.2 BB/9. This profile feels more like what Seattle used to target in the Gilbert, Kirby, Hancock era.

Dohm has college eligibility remaining, so I’m not sure we go underslot on him, but we have enough bonus saved that we could go overslot on him if we really needed to. For now, I’m allotting him exactly slot money.

Backup plan: I think there’s a grouping of prep pitchers in this range that are very interesting including LHP Ethan Schiefelbein, LHP Mason Russell, RHP Jackson Barberi, LHP Mason Brassfield.

4.121 – 3B, Central Bucks East HS, Chase Harlan

In 2023, Seattle had the three picks in the first round which became the three high school hitters. But subplot to that was that they went back to high school hitter in the 4th round with an overslot deal to OF Aidan Smith. Smith was MLB’s #78 ranked player, and Seattle got him at #124. The slot where he was drafted was $531k and they signed him for $1.2mill. I love this move at this range. There’s inevitably a pocket of high school players that wanted second round money, but just hadn’t found a fit with a team.

Harlan is a bit of an arbitrary pick here. I don’t know that he will be on the board still (MLB ranks him #112), I don’t know that he will be willing to sign away from commitment to Clemson. Harlan is young for the class (actually turns 18 next week), but he’s already 6’3″/210lbs and has some of the biggest shoulders I’ve ever seen on a high schooler. He posted some of the top 5 hardest hit EV’s at the recent MLB Combine against a mix of college and high school players. But on top of the brute strength tool, I believe I found that he only struck out 5 times in the entire HS season (about 7% K-rate). So he’s potentially pretty disciplined, as well.

This is definitely overslot, but it’s just a question of how much. I’m gonna earmark an even $1.5mill to get him signed.

Backup plan: overslotting a different high school player that has fallen from higher ranking.

5.154 – C, Bishop Gorman HS, Burke-Lee Mabeus

I sort of have it in my head that Harry Ford is not long for the organization. He will be the biggest piece of the biggest trade Seattle is going to need to make in the next few weeks. So, I’d like to find some youth at the catching position to go with the savvy, defensive receiver I will add from the college ranks later this mock.

Mabeus is a 6’3″/210lb, switch-hitting prep catcher with a commitment to Oregon. He’s ranked #159 overall by MLB.com, so the positioning makes sense, and it’s just a question of signability. Again, we can offer him probably $1mill overslot no problem, but we might get it done with about $700k extra. I will call it a $1mill total bonus for ease of tracking.

I really love both swings from Burke-Lee, and we’ve had success with SH catchers recently, and technically we did draft Adley Rutschman out of high school back in 2016 when he was committed to an Oregon college.

Backup plan: I still like local high school SS Adam Haight.

6.183 – RHP, William and Mary, Nate Knowles

I have a hunch that Knowles will be highly sought after by the Seattle analytics room. He’s only 6’0″/205lbs, but he’s young for the class as a 20-year-old Junior, and he’s doing stuff with pitch metrics that are intriguing. His season line was tremendous: 2.48 ERA, 1.113 WHIP, 12.6 SO/9.

7.213 – LHP, Rutgers, Donovan Zsak

It’s a bit of a priority for me to find A) some kind of LHP starting options to add to a roster that is currently filled by five RHP starters in a home park that you should probably want as many LHP as possible, B) some high-octane, fast-moving relievers as the entire farm is woefully inept out of the ‘pen right now. Zsak is potentially both.

Zsak is a 6’3″/185lb southpaw with only one year of college experience, but is draft eligible as a guy turning 21 two days before the draft. His college season went 4.11 ERA, 1.200 WHIP, 10.0 SO/9 in 35.0 innings out of the bullpen, but he’s currently adding starting work in the Cape Cod League where he’s got 12 K’s in only 7.1 innings (14.7 SO/9) and a 0.955 WHIP. I feel like he’s about to take off, and I’m really eager to buy low on him. But with the amount of college eligibility he has left, it can’t be buying TOO low.

8.243 – MIF, Austin Peay, Jon Jon Gazdar

Gazdar is a 5’11″/180lb infielder that played exclusively shortstop for Austin Peay, but in two weeks of games in the Cape League he’s been mostly at 2B, with some time at 3B and SS, and looks to me like a future 2B is one of the best contact hitters in the country with only 14 SO in 237 AB’s (5.9%), while walking 27 times. The slash line went .405/.484/1.151 with 13 HR, 55 RBI, and 9×10 SB. He would be so reminiscent of last year’s 5th rounder Brock Rodden, who has been a very solid performer already reaching AA in his first full year of pro ball. Seattle needs high-floor, fast-moving position players like this to go with the fast-moving bullpen arms.

9.273 – RHP, Miami, Brian Walters

The more time I’ve had post-NFL Draft; the more relievers I’ve been able to find. Over the last week I’ve actually been able to go roster by roster across three of the Power 5 conferences, and that process revealed two guys in this mock to me.

Walters is a 6’3″/194lb reliever recently returned to Miami from TJ surgery, and he threw 13.2 innings in 2024 across 15 appearances. ERA was 3.29, WHIP of 1.024, and 14.5 SO/9.

10.303 – OF, Austin Peay, Lyle Miller Green

Returning from previous mocks; Miller Green is a 6’5″/237lb outfielder that hit .393/.533/1.432 last year with 30 HR and 94 RBI. The ONLY reason he’s potentially available this late is because he will be 24 in September. In terms of just the bat; this is one of the best values available in the entire draft. If you have to pick him earlier, probably worth it. The floor here might be righthanded Luke Raley.

11.333 – LHP, Oklahoma State, Sam Garcia

The M’s have done something pretty interesting the last 2-3 drafts wherein they devote most of their picks in the 10th-15th rounds to drafting college pitchers. I love this idea and I’m sticking with it in this mock.

Garcia is a 6’4″/218lb LHP that actually became of the highest-rated LHP starting pitchers in my pitch metric. He’s not ranked very high by draft outlets because of the lack of high-velo stuff. But this profile has proven effective in Tmobile Park. In 2024 he posted 3.64 ERA, 1.079 WHIP, 11.6 SO/9 in 16 starts.

12.363 – RHP, UCSB, Ryan Gallagher

Gallagher represents a very similar profile as Garcia, but from the righthand side. At 6’3″/195lbs, he had a 2.22 ERA, 0.843 WHIP, 9.7 SO/9 with more pitchability than stuff.

13.393 – LHP, Oklahoma State, Ryan Ure

Ure is the polar opposite of his college teammate Garcia. He is all power stuff, with a pretty glaring lack of pitchability/control. At 6’8″/234lbs, Ure is a massive man with a massive 103mph fastball that led to a 17.2 SO/9 rate in his limited work in 2024, after missing all of 2023 with an injury. So there are multiple redflags here, but on day 3 of the draft it sort of doesn’t matter. If you can fix/maintain Ure’s arm; you potentially have years of Aroldis Chapman lite.

14.423 – RHP, Kansas, Hunter Cranton

I sort of feel like this is much too late to be targeting Cranton, but I also feel that way about 90% of my picks in every mock. But I’m placing him a full round or two ahead of the national media ranking, and seeing if that’s enough compensation. Hunter is a 6’3″/210lb reliever at 23 years old who posted a 2.16 ERA, 1.200 WHIP, 13.7 SO/9 across 25 innings last year.

15.453 – RHP, Arizona, Dawson Netz

Netz is 6’1″/203lbs and this year posted a 4.29 ERA, 1.143 WHIP, and 11.6 SO/9 out of the Arizona bullpen.

16.483 – SS, Murray State, Drew Vogel

These last five picks will all be position players, and could really be made in any order. I tried to find good athletes with well-rounded toolsets. I’m basically just taking them in an order based on defensive position priority. We start with the shortstop. Vogel is a 6’1″/195lbs SS that hit .331/.441/1.097 last year with 20 HR, 61 RBI, and 16×17 SB.

17.513 – C, James Madison, Jason Schiavone

Schiavone is a 6’2″/208lb catcher with above average catch and throw defense, that also hit .284/.400/1.020 with 18 HR, 51 RBI, 9×12 SB last year.

18.543 – 3B, NC State, Alec Makarewicz

Makarewicz is a big, strong 6’3″/234lb 3B that can switch-hit to the tune of .378/.438/1.191 with 24 HR, 84 RBI and some very clutch hits in this year’s CWS.

19.573 – OF, Evansville, Mark Shallenberger

Shallenberger reminds me a bit of Hunter Pence. It’s not pretty, but it’s effective. At 6’2″/220lbs he hit .375/.514/1.201 with 17 HR, 64 RBI, and an incredibly disciplined 45 BB to 28 SO.

20.603 – 1B, Northeastern, Tyler MacGregor

MacGregor is 6’3″/215lbs and hit .402/.484/1.270 with19 HR, 80 RBI and a very solid 15×17 SB from the firstbase position.

As we progress through the tail end of the Covid year era, there should be quite the class of undrafted players available this year. I’d look for the Mariners to sign another 6-10 guys that route after the draft ends.